This text was produced for ProPublica’s Native Reporting Community in partnership with The Current. Sign up for Dispatches to get tales like this one as quickly as they’re printed.
Congressional Republicans, on the lookout for methods to offset their proposed tax cuts, are in search of to mandate that tens of millions of Individuals work in an effort to obtain federally sponsored medical health insurance. The GOP tax and funds invoice handed the Home in Could, and Senate Republicans are working feverishly to advance their draft of federal spending cuts within the coming days.
Georgia, the only state with a Medicaid work mandate, began experimenting with the requirement on July 1, 2023. Because the Medicaid program’s two-year anniversary approaches, Georgia has enrolled only a fraction of these eligible, a consequence well being coverage researchers largely attribute to bureaucratic hurdles within the state’s work verification system. As of Could 2025, roughly 7,500 of the almost 250,000 eligible Georgians had been enrolled, despite the fact that state statistics present 64% of that group is working.
Gov. Brian Kemp has lengthy advocated for Medicaid reform, arguing that the nation ought to transfer away from government-run well being care. His spokesperson additionally advised The Present and ProPublica that this system, referred to as Georgia Pathways to Protection, was never designed to maximize enrollment.
Well being care analysts and former state Medicaid officers say Georgia’s experience exhibits that the congressional invoice, if it turns into legislation, would value taxpayers lots of of tens of millions of {dollars} in administrative prices as it’s applied whereas threatening well being look after nearly 16 million people.
Right here’s how proposed federal work necessities examine to Georgia’s — and the way they might affect your state:
How will states decide who’s eligible?
What Congress proposes:
The House bill, H.R. 1, and draft Senate proposal require all states to confirm that Individuals ages 19 via 64 who’re receiving Medicaid-funded well being protection are spending 80 hours a month working, coaching for a job, learning or volunteering. These new verification programs would must be in place by Dec. 31, 2026, and must verify on enrolled residents’ work standing twice a 12 months. Which means individuals who already obtain protection based mostly on their earnings degree would wish to routinely show their eligibility — or lose their insurance coverage.
The federal work necessities would apply to greater than 10 million low-income adults with Medicaid protection in addition to roughly 5 million residents of the 40 states which have accepted federal subsidies for individuals to buy personal well being protection via what’s generally referred to as Obamacare.
The Home invoice exempts dad and mom with kids below 18 from the brand new necessities, whereas the Senate model exempts dad and mom with kids below 15. Neither invoice exempts individuals who take care of aged family members.
Georgia’s expertise:
Georgia’s mandate applies to fewer classes of individuals than the proposed federal laws would. Even so, officers failed to satisfy the state’s powerful month-to-month verification requirement for Pathways enrollees attributable to technical glitches and issue confirming the employment of those that work within the casual financial system reminiscent of home cleaners and landscapers as a result of they might not have pay stubs or tax data. The challenges had been steep sufficient that Georgia has determined to loosen its work verification protocols from month-to-month to annually.
What this implies to your state:
The Congressional Finances Workplace estimates that H.R. 1 would lead to not less than 10 million low-income Americans shedding medical health insurance. Well being care advocates say that’s not as a result of they aren’t working, however due to the bureaucratic hoops they would wish to leap via to show employment. Research from KFF, a well being coverage assume tank, exhibits that the overwhelming majority of people that could be topic to the brand new legislation already work, are enrolled in class or are unpaid stay-at-home caregivers, duties that prohibit their means to earn a wage elsewhere.
Arkansas is the one state aside from Georgia to have applied work necessities. Republican state lawmakers later modified their minds after information confirmed that purple tape related to verifying eligibility resulted in additional than 18,000 individuals shedding protection throughout the first few months of the coverage. A federal choose halted this system in 2019, ruling that it elevated the state’s uninsured price with none proof of elevated employment.
Credit score:
Tom Williams/CQ Roll Name by way of AP
Home Speaker Mike Johnson, a Louisiana Republican, says Medicaid work necessities in H.R. 1 are “common sense.” He says the coverage gained’t lead to well being protection losses for the Individuals whom Medicaid was initially designed to assist as a result of the work necessities gained’t apply to those teams: kids, pregnant ladies and aged individuals dwelling in poverty. He factors to the $344 billion in a decade’s value of projected value financial savings ensuing from Medicaid work necessities as helpful to the nation’s fiscal well being. “You discover dignity in work, and the individuals that aren’t doing that, we’re going to attempt to get their consideration,” he stated earlier this 12 months.
Who pays for the work verification system in every state?
What Congress proposes:
The Home invoice allocates $100 million to assist states pay for verification programs that decide somebody’s eligibility. The grants could be distributed in proportion to every state’s share of Medicaid enrollees topic to the brand new necessities — an quantity well being coverage specialists say won’t be almost sufficient. States, they are saying, might be on the hook for the distinction.
Georgia’s expertise:
Within the two years since launching its experiment with work necessities, Georgia has spent almost $100 million in principally federal funds to implement Pathways. Of that, $55 million went towards constructing a digital system to confirm individuals’ eligibility — greater than half the quantity Home Republicans allotted for the whole nation to do the identical factor.
Like different states, Georgia already had a piece verification system in place for meals stamp applications, however it contracted with Deloitte Consulting to deal with its new Medicaid necessities. Georgia officers stated the state has spent 30% greater than that they had anticipated to create its digital platform for Pathways attributable to rising marketing consultant and IT prices. Deloitte beforehand declined to reply questions on its Pathways work.
What this implies to your state:
All states already confirm work necessities for meals stamp recipients, however many current programs would wish upgrades to evolve to proposed federal laws, in keeping with three former state Medicaid officers. In 2019, when states final thought-about work necessities, a survey by the nonpartisan Government Accountability Office confirmed that Kentucky anticipated administrative prices to prime $200 million — double what H.R. 1 has allotted for the nation.
Credit score:
Justin Taylor/The Present GA/CatchLight Native
Rep. Buddy Carter, the Republican who represents coastal Georgia and chairs the well being subcommittee of the Home Vitality and Commerce Committee, which had really useful Medicaid cuts in H.R. 1, stated that upfront prices borne by states could be offset by longer-term financial savings promised within the Home invoice. Some congressional Republicans concede that the fee financial savings will come from fewer individuals enrolling in Medicaid as a result of new necessities. Financial savings from work mandates quantity to 43% of the $793 billion in proposed Medicaid cuts, in keeping with the Congressional Finances Workplace.
How will states employees this system?
What Congress proposes:
Medicaid is a federal social security internet program that’s administered in a different way in every state. Neither H.R. 1 nor the Senate legislative proposal supplies a blueprint for the way states ought to confirm eligibility or how the prices of overseeing the brand new necessities might be paid.
Georgia’s expertise:
Georgia’s expertise exhibits that state caseworkers are key to managing purposes and work requirement verifications for residents eligible for Medicaid. The company that handles enrollment in federal advantages had a employees emptiness price of roughly 20% when Georgia launched its work requirement coverage in 2023. Georgia on the time had one of many longest wait instances for approving federal advantages. As of March, the company had a backlog of greater than 5,000 Pathways purposes. The company has stated it’ll want 300 extra caseworkers and IT upgrades to higher handle the backlog, in keeping with a report submitted to state lawmakers in June.
What this implies to your state:
Former state Medicaid officers and well being coverage specialists say Georgia’s staffing struggles should not distinctive. In 2023, close to the tip of the COVID-19 public well being emergency, KFF surveyed states about staffing ranges for caseworkers who confirm eligibility for federal advantages, together with Medicaid. Employee vacancy rates exceeded 10% in 16 of the 26 states that responded; charges exceeded 20% in seven of these states.
Including caseworkers will imply larger prices for states. At the moment, 41 states require a balanced funds, which means that these state legislators would both want to extend taxes and revenues to confirm Medicaid enrollees are working or decrease enrollment to scale back prices, stated Joan Alker, govt director of Georgetown College’s Heart for Youngsters and Households.
In about half a dozen giant states the place county governments administer federal security internet applications, the prices of coaching caseworkers on the brand new verification protocols may trickle from states to counties.
“There are provisions in there which can be very, very, very difficult, if not inconceivable, for us to implement,” Sen. Lisa Murkowski, an Alaska Republican, advised reporters in June of the prices going through her state to satisfy the Home invoice necessities.
