She violated each journalism ethics code. However her childhood set her as much as fall for a string of incompetent daddy-figures too lame to guard her.
Olivia Nuzzi on the White Home Correspondents’ Affiliation dinner in Washington, DC, in 2023, when she was Washington correspondent for New York journal.
(Jose Luis Magana / AP Images)
Olivia Nuzzi has all the time identified methods to spot a superb story, particularly when she will be able to put herself in the midst of it. The now-infamous journalist, who misplaced a coveted submit as Washington correspondent for New York journal final 12 months when particulars emerged that she’d had a sexting romance with now Well being and Human Companies Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. after profiling him, is again with a brand new guide, American Canto, and a publicity tour about the entire sordid scenario. Primarily about herself.
However she first got here to nationwide consideration when she wrote a tell-all for the New York Day by day Information about Anthony Weiner’s doomed (by his personal sexting, and extra) 2013 mayoral marketing campaign—from the viewpoint of the 20-year-old marketing campaign intern she had been for roughly a month. (The primary revelation? He known as her, and several other different interns, by the identify “Monica.” No remark.)
Associated Article
I’ve a imprecise reminiscence of defending Nuzzi on Twitter, and getting a digital thank-you from her, when Weiner’s communications director came after her in crude, sexist phrases, calling her a “bitch,” “slutbag,” “twat,” and “cunt,” promising to wreck her in New York. I needn’t have fearful about her; Nuzzi appeared to get the final phrase, for some time, turning her new fame right into a job as New York’s first-ever Washington correspondent on the age of twenty-two.
Having misplaced that prestigious perch final 12 months over her secret sext affair with Kennedy, Nuzzi might need thought American Canto would give her one other final phrase. Alas, it has not. Earlier than the guide was even revealed, her former fiance, Ryan Lizza—himself let go by The New Yorker over a what the journal known as “improper sexual conduct”—used his ex’s emergence from exile to throw his underwhelming Substack into overdrive, with a so-far four-part exposé of Nuzzi’s romantic and journalistic misdeeds, which, if true, go far past some gross sexting with a grosser-still politician (or “The Politician,” as she pretentiously calls him in her memoir).
I didn’t wish to know any of this, however it’s my job. You possibly can resolve whether or not to learn on, or not.
However first let me Nuzzi myself, at the very least briefly. I do know a lot of the unhappy bold-faced names on this story. I first crossed paths with Lizza once I wrote a couple of options for The New Republic within the final century, whereas he was only a baby beginning on the market, and I noticed him usually over the following many years, remaining vaguely pleasant as he soared excessive above me, socially and professionally. I grew to become Twitter-friendly with Nuzzi after defending her from Weiner’s sexist comms director (who it seems grew to become one in every of Nuzzi’s shut real-life pals, due to course; her guide tells us she’s additionally pals with mean-girl doyennes Maureen Dowd and Sally Quinn), and he or she all the time greeted me semi-warmly at political occasions.
Present Concern
Whereas I used to be defending the (I assumed) defenseless faculty scholar in opposition to the Weiner marketing campaign, it seems Nuzzi was courting and/or dwelling with then–MSNBC titan Keith Olbermann (34 years her senior), whom I edited when he was (briefly) a Salon columnist. (Lizza dished about their relationship in Half One in all his feverish posts.) Olbermann, removed from his Countdown fame peak, took the chance to confirm and even elaborate on Lizza’s disclosures, ensuring everyone knows that he gave Nuzzi tens of 1000’s of {dollars} of costly designer garments and jewellery, as a result of what else was he speculated to do… “Get her Reward Certificates from Kmart?” No, I’m not making that up. He stated that.
Oh, I additionally edited Kennedy on a chunk (on the nonexistent hyperlink between autism and vaccines) that Salon wound up retracting. One of many worst experiences in my skilled life. One of many worst individuals I’ve ever identified.
I’ve usually felt barely icky about myself once I take into consideration realizing any of these individuals, as I’ve watched them carry out, usually shamefully, on the political stage—even earlier than I knew what they did of their private lives, typically behind each other’s backs. I might have favored all of this to have stayed behind my again.
However hey, I’m paid to be powerful about depravity. Particularly when it’s discovered on the highest ranges of journalism and politics.
Regardless of all this, I nonetheless really feel a little bit bit sorry for Olivia.
Let me backtrack a little bit, un-Nuzzi myself, if you’ll. Let me begin over with an old school inverted-pyramid-style story. For those who’re not a information junkie, which we be taught Nuzzi was not—in keeping with a recent fawning profile in The New York Instances, “Nuzzi cared much less about breaking information than about exposing the foibles and vainness of Trump and the individuals inside his orbit”—an inverted-pyramid story tells you what’s massive and necessary, on the prime, after which will get into smaller particulars—like, say, the “erotic” poetry RFK Jr.’s despatched to Nuzzi, or his brainworm—a lot later. (I’m ignoring the allegedly erotic poetry.)
So if I had been beginning over, I’d say American Canto is a tragic and bizarrely instructed story a couple of motherless woman who technically did have a mom effectively into maturity, and a daddy’s woman whose sanitation employee father did his greatest however couldn’t shield her from her abusive, alcoholic mom. Each died younger. That’s the story. (Additionally, paternal Grandpa Tony left his spouse for a 16-year-old, she says.) Nuzzi dates creepy older males as a result of she nonetheless craves Daddy’s safety—however she additionally hates them as a result of they’ll’t shield her, not even from herself.
Oh, additionally: That is actually a guide about Donald Trump, whom she usually profiled for New York over the past decade, though the Trump components are a jumbled mess, typically actually a pocket book dump of outdated interviews she by no means revealed verbatim. However Trump is the final word Daddy determine, and whereas I’ve no proof, perception, suspicion (and even curiosity about) whether or not something “romantic” went on between them, ick, we get many extra particulars about their many creepy-if-chaste interactions than we do about her sexting (and marketing campaign consulting, which is damning) with Kennedy. Typically American Canto, an virtually self-satirizing title, appears to be saying, “Trump made me do it,” all of the tawdry conduct, all of the sexual posing (the guide makes it appear she identifies with Jon Benet Ramsey and Marilyn Monroe and Sharon Tate, and we all know how they ended up). Nuzzi clearly is aware of that being a sizzling, younger blonde acquired and stored Trump’s consideration, even when a few of what she wrote about him wasn’t flattering. Though nothing was as vicious as what she wrote about President Joe Biden simply as his marketing campaign, which she described as a Weekend at Bernie’s endeavor, crashed and burned.
She nonetheless clearly has a smooth spot for the adjudicated rapist, the convicted prison fraudster, the seditionist who pardoned violent seditionists when, unbelievably, he returned to the White Home this 12 months. In her final (identified) interview with him, revealed at inexplicable size within the guide, she flatters Trump as an “artist” and notes that he “introduced present enterprise to enterprise.” They’ve an excellent rapport with each other. Studying the guide, whereas she appears to be saying “Trump made me do that,” you may also end up considering, “However Olivia, you gave us Trump.” Not alone, after all. Numerous American voters love that Large Creepy Daddy; a variety of different journalists rolled over for him, not out of affection, except you rely love of entry, and the cash and fame that include it.
OK, what else do that you must find out about this unhappy guide? Whereas Lizza is getting “credit score” for revealing a few of Nuzzi’s worst misdeeds on behalf of Kennedy, like tipping him off to a number of the unhealthy tales (oh, that poor bear cub) surfacing about him, she truly type of tells a variety of it herself, in her imprecise, seemingly barely stoned fashion. No, she doesn’t cop to having an affair with former South Carolina governor Mark Sanford, as Lizza alleged, the well-known Lothario of the Appalachian Path, whereas she was masking his presidential marketing campaign in 2019 (admit it, you blinked and missed it, I do know I did). That’s Lizza’s massive reveal in Half I of his sometime legendary (he hopes) “How I Discovered Out.” Though she confesses to doing a variety of assist work for Kennedy in her guide, Lizza reveals far more, and I concern that her rehabilitation tour, centered on not simply the guide but additionally a brand new job as West Coast editor for Self-importance Truthful, might run aground on a number of the particulars.
I write that “I concern” as if I care about her. I don’t, actually, however then once more, I do. Though I nonetheless assume she ought to lose this newest job.
As we’re nonetheless taking within the horror revealed in so most of the Jeffrey Epstein e-mails (we nonetheless don’t have the Justice Division “recordsdata”), as we’re nonetheless understanding the despicable Lolita tradition of our elites, it’s exhausting to see this younger lady—she’s nonetheless solely 32—preyed upon by older males when she was 19 or 20. Olbermann admits that he isn’t certain how younger she was once they began courting. (People, she put out her personal “rap” video, known as “Jailbait,” on MySpace when she was 15. Underneath the identify “Livvy,” which everybody from her dad to Bobby Jr. known as her.) She started seeing Lizza, 19 years her senior once they began out, at 22; RFK Jr. was a full 34 years older. Nevertheless it appears she was over 30 when that started, so regardless that he was married and can also be apparently a sociopath, perhaps that wasn’t as abusive? I don’t know.
You actually can’t forgive Nuzzi all her unhealthy judgment. She roots for Kennedy to get confirmed as HHS secretary—she has a weird, waking-dream account of watching his affirmation listening to from afar, as she prays for him. Kennedy is, in Olbermann’s outdated parlance, one of many “worst individuals on the earth.” He’s imply, vindictive, and mentally in poor health, and can trigger the illness and loss of life of many Individuals, if he hasn’t already. Nuzzi is outdated and sensible sufficient to know that. Or needs to be. She worries about his reported brainworm, and takes solace in his promise he by no means had a brainworm. “Child, don’t fear, it’s not a worm,” he reassured her.
OK, nice, however keep in mind, his legal professionals concocted his brainworm story to cheat his spouse (who later dedicated suicide) out of earnings she believed she was owed of their divorce. The brainworm supposedly minimize into his incomes potential as a proficient lawyer. No, actually, and that story is as ludicrous as something in Nuzzi’s guide. She is so relieved to be taught that he didn’t have a brainworm, ignoring why he made it up within the first place. (Additionally, WTF was it, if not a brainworm?)
However then once more, why would she care that he tried to cheat his late ex-wife? She passes alongside horrible allegations (that I’ve by no means seen confirmed) about her. Very like her image of her mother and father, she claims Bobby tried to defend his youngsters from their abusive mom, however failed. Nuzzi is simply too outdated to be absolved from these ethical, political, and journalistic sins.
Well-liked
“swipe left under to view extra authors”Swipe →
And Lizza does reveal some alleged journalistic sins she doesn’t. He closed his breathless Substack Half III with a touch that she discovered one thing (the small print are too uninteresting and complex) concerning the alleged assassination try on Trump in Butler, Pennsylvania, in August 2024, “one thing explosive that, if she had been right, would shatter our understanding of current historical past.” Nuzzi’s final revealed story for New York featured her go to to Trump to examine his allegedly wounded ear (and extra, after all). In Half IV, he doesn’t fairly ship on his promise: There was allegedly a recording of Trump made by a Nuzzi colleague that featured the president elevating doubts concerning the official story of the try. However when Lizza listens to the tape, he says, it’s of such poor high quality he can’t ensure what if something it reveals—and Nuzzi in the end erases it.
If she had one thing that “explosive,” and didn’t reveal it, that’s horrific. However like so a lot of Lizza’s revelations: If true, one might argue that he had a journalistic obligation to come back ahead himself. So I actually don’t know what to consider. And in some unspecified time in the future, I’ve to cease making an attempt to determine it out.
These deeply disturbed individuals are our journalistic elites, my pals. And also you surprise why our democracy is hanging by a thread?
I do know that many necessary organizations are asking you to donate at the moment, however this 12 months particularly, The Nation wants your assist.
Over the course of 2025, the Trump administration has presided over a authorities designed to sit back activism and dissent.
The Nation skilled its efforts to destroy press freedom firsthand in September, when Vice President JD Vance attacked our journal. Vance was following Donald Trump’s lead—waging struggle on the media by means of a sequence of lawsuits in opposition to publications and broadcasters, all supposed to intimidate these talking fact to energy.
The Nation won’t ever yield to those menacing currents. Now we have survived for 160 years and we’ll proceed difficult new types of intimidation, simply as we refused to bow to McCarthyism seven many years in the past. However on this horrifying media surroundings, we’re counting on you to assist us fund journalism that successfully challenges Trump’s crude authoritarianism.
For at the moment solely, a beneficiant donor is matching all presents to The Nation as much as $25,000. If we hit our aim this Giving Tuesday, that’s $50,000 for journalism with a way of urgency.
Along with your assist, we’ll proceed to publish investigations that expose the administration’s corruption, evaluation that sounds the alarm on AI’s unregulated seize of the navy, and profiles of the inspiring tales of people that efficiently tackle the ICE terror machine.
We’ll additionally introduce you to the brand new faces and concepts on this progressive second, similar to we did with New York Metropolis Mayor-elect Zohran Mamdani. We are going to all the time consider {that a} extra simply tomorrow is in our energy at the moment.
Please, don’t miss this chance to double your impact. Donate to The Nation today.
Katrina vanden Heuvel
Editor and writer, The Nation
Extra from The Nation
Along with his approval quantity plummeting, Trump turns to a well-recognized technique: launch a tradition struggle in opposition to journalists.
Don’t simply freeze the lease of rent-stabilized items. Don’t enable their demolition in any respect.
Trump’s boat bombings deserve authorized retribution, but additionally present why we’d like a wholly new international coverage.
