The preliminary chaos of layoffs has been adopted by a concerted effort by the Trump administration to halt the enforcement of the Truthful Housing Act.
The Division of Housing and City Growth (HUD) headquarters in Washington, DC.
(Stefani Reynolds / Bloomberg through Getty Photos)
Kenneth Hansbrough’s issues started with a key fob. Hansbrough, who makes use of a wheelchair on account of a spinal wire illness and is legally blind, moved right into a low-income residence in St Louis, Missouri, three years in the past. If Hansbrough falls, his son, who lives close by, might help him, so he gave his son a key to his residence. However to get within the constructing his son additionally wants a fob for the entrance door, and Hansbrough’s landlord will solely give him an additional one if he pays $50, cash Hansbrough doesn’t have. So now, when he falls and wishes assist, he calls the hearth division to drive its approach into the constructing and break down his door to get him up. “They’ve carried out it twice,” he famous.
Subsequent Hansbrough requested his landlord for a tool that will permit him to open the gate to the massive car parking zone behind the constructing. Hansbrough depends on town’s Name-A-Trip service for transportation to every thing from physician appointments to the grocery retailer. However the entrance of his constructing, the place the Name-A-Trip often picks him up, is true close to a freeway onramp, and if the six avenue parking areas are taken Hansbrough is compelled to danger his security going onto the sidewalk proper close to the onramp, which is “very harmful,” he stated. He requested his landlord for entry to the car parking zone, however he was denied—he doesn’t have a automobile, so he doesn’t qualify, he was informed.
Then there’s his rest room. The bathe has a lip about 10 inches excessive. To get in, Hansbrough raises the seat of his wheelchair all the way in which up—which he’s not presupposed to do—after which tries to ease himself in. Getting out when he’s moist is much more harmful. He’s fallen a number of occasions, so he avoids bathing. “It’s completely irritating and I hate it,” he stated. “I would like to have the ability to take a bathe with out placing my life at risk.” He requested his landlord to put in a seize bar he purchased himself over the bathroom, however one night time when he tried to make use of it it got here out of the wall and hit him on the top, which made him knock his head on the bathroom, leaving him with a concussion. He’s informed his landlord in regards to the issues with the lavatory, however aside from the shoddy seize bar set up he says he’s been ignored.
“It’s simply been one horrible ordeal,” he stated.
All of Hansbrough’s requests ought to have been easy lodging for individuals with disabilities which are required of landlords underneath federal legislation. So in January 2024, Hansbrough availed himself of his rights underneath the Truthful Housing Act—a key Civil Rights-era legislation enacted in 1968 that prohibits discrimination in housing on the idea of race, shade, faith, intercourse, nationwide origin, familial standing, and incapacity—and filed a criticism with the Division of Housing and City Growth (HUD). “Some truthful housing circumstances are sophisticated. A few of them have details that could be topic to interpretation,” stated Kalila Jackson, a volunteer lawyer with the Metropolitan St. Louis Equal Housing Alternative Council who’s representing Hansbrough. “This was actually black and white.”
Present Difficulty
HUD started investigating Hansbrough’s case over a 12 months in the past and, earlier than January, had begun negotiations along with his landlord. However Hansbrough’s case is one in every of many to be fully upended by the second Trump administration, which has basically stopped implementing civil rights at HUD solely.
At first, HUD civil rights circumstances have been “shuffled” between workers, Jackson stated, when DOGE layoffs and early retirement enticements led to an exodus. HUD’s Workplace of Truthful Housing and Equal Alternative (FHEO), which enforces the Truthful Housing Act, has skilled a 65 p.c staffing discount, going from 31 staff to 11, for the reason that begin of the 12 months. That was earlier than one other 114 FHEO staff were fired by the administration in the course of the current authorities shutdown. The investigator on Hansbrough’s case was a probationary worker and was fired within the initial layoffs in February, so a brand new investigator was assigned. His case didn’t transfer ahead for months; the brand new investigator who was assigned by no means spoke to Jackson or Hansbrough, she stated.
Jackson has different circumstances with out an investigator on them in any respect. “We’re being informed, ‘You possibly can preserve asking for updates, however I’ve nothing to let you know,’” she stated. “Nothing is transferring in any respect.”
“The federal government is shutting down HUD systemically,” Jackson added. “It rolls again the clock to the pre-Civil Rights age.”
The preliminary chaos of layoffs and resignations has been adopted by a concerted effort by the Trump administration to halt the enforcement of the Truthful Housing Act at HUD. In response to dozens of emails and communications reviewed by the New York Times, Trump appointees have made it “almost inconceivable” for these usually tasked with this work to do their jobs. HUD whistleblowers say they’ve been subjected to a “gag order” that forestalls them from speaking instantly with exterior events, reducing then off from speaking to victims of discrimination or the entities being accused with out getting approval from a Trump appointee, approval that’s “not often granted.” As Paul Osadebe, a trial lawyer in HUD’s Workplace of Truthful Housing, informed The Nation, “Nobody would rent a lawyer who can’t speak to them.” As of September, FHEO staff should get approval earlier than settlements or fees may be issued, in line with a memo that John Gibbs, Trump’s appointee to Principal Deputy Help Secretary at HUD’s Workplace of Coverage Growth & Analysis, despatched to workers. That’s allowed political appointees to unilaterally change settlement phrases or reject compensation quantities for victims of discrimination.
Gibbs’s memo additionally said that circumstances involving gender id, screening for felony backgrounds, environmental justice, appraisal bias, or native zoning are primarily based on “tenuous theories of discrimination” and “will not be prioritized.” Steerage on redlining and reverse redlining are “legally unsound,” he wrote, and received’t be utilized in enforcement. He additionally rescinded company steering on disparate influence discrimination—the authorized doctrine that holds actions or insurance policies are discriminatory if they’ve a disproportionate influence on protected teams, even when these impacts aren’t intentional—in addition to different steering paperwork associated to individuals with restricted English or with out documented standing. Different paperwork the Times reviewed stated the work of the FHEO is “not a precedence of the administration.” Since Trump took workplace, Osadebe has but to see a civil rights declare HUD was prepared to pursue, he stated. “We don’t do something.”
The company is now implementing these priorities, or lack thereof, on state and native truthful housing businesses which are paid by HUD to course of about 20 percent of all discrimination complaints (HUD itself handles only about five percent of complaints, with nonprofit truthful housing teams dealing with three-quarters). In a memo despatched to all such company administrators shared with The Nation, Nathan S. Roth, performing director of workplace of packages at FHEO, wrote that circumstances of discrimination primarily based on gender id, sexual orientation, rental voucher use, felony data, restricted English, and weight and peak “won’t be reimbursed.” It additionally threatened to tug these businesses’ capacity to course of discrimination claims on HUD’s behalf in the event that they implement native truthful housing legal guidelines which are extra protecting than the federal baseline. If the memo pushes these businesses to cease doing this work, “That’s going to be as huge a deal as HUD basically going out of enterprise,” stated Sasha Samberg-Champion, particular counsel for civil rights on the Nationwide Truthful Housing Alliance who served as deputy normal counsel for enforcement and truthful housing and HUD underneath President Biden.
In the meantime, the administration terminated grants for a lot of housing nonprofits and different authorized advocacy organizations that additionally cope with discrimination complaints, funding that was appropriated by Congress, and “has but to show that cash again on,” Samberg-Champion stated. That implies that the organizations that deal with most housing discrimination complaints have spent a 12 months “getting their funding on and off,” possible resulting in layoffs and fewer enforcement capability. Trump’s proposed funds eliminates their funding solely.
“They’re attacking efficient truthful housing enforcement throughout any mechanism that they’ve,” Samberg-Champion stated. “They’re pulling each lever to make it inconceivable to implement your rights underneath the Truthful Housing Act.”
HUD has additionally withdrawn not less than three fees, by which HUD had discovered proof of lawbreaking and both put the case in entrance of an administrative legislation decide or handed it over to the Division of Justice, which it lacks the authorized authority to do. That leaves claimants “scrambling,” Osadebe stated, to “begin over and get one other lawyer if they will discover one.” Different fees which are able to be introduced, in the meantime, are “sitting on a desk someplace, they’re simply refusing to go ahead,” Osadebe stated. Tons of of circumstances are frozen, in line with the Occasions. HUD has additionally withdrawn settlements that have been reached years in the past. Many settlements final over a interval of years, and HUD stays concerned to ensure the phrases are met and the victims aren’t retaliated towards. That’s not taking place within the ones it’s yanked.
“When you’re not implementing the Truthful Housing Act, then it’s simply one other useless legislation,” Palmer Heenan, a profession lawyer on the FHEO, told the Occasions. He was fired after the article got here out. Osadebe has been advisable for removing.
The results of the administration’s actions is an absence of reduction and justice for individuals like Hansbrough. Over the past 5 years, the FHEO has collected between $4 million and $8 million a 12 months by means of authorized settlements in discrimination circumstances. However between January and July of this 12 months, it accredited settlements totaling lower than $200,000, according to the Times. Prices have fallen from a mean of 25 a 12 months to simply 4 for the reason that begin of 2025.
Standard
“swipe left beneath to view extra authors”Swipe →
In July, HUD determined to shut Hansbrough’s case. “I used to be shocked,” he stated. “I simply felt like I had nobody however Ms. Jackson to help me.” Jackson stated the doc outlining HUD’s determination “was wildly inconsistent with the truth.”
Within the meantime, his landlord has tried to evict him a number of occasions although he insists he pays his hire forward of time and he hasn’t broken any property. The newest try got here in early October simply after HUD dismissed his case.
Hansbrough can’t transfer, although. He lives on a set earnings, surviving solely on Social Safety Incapacity funds and Missouri’s Blind Pension Program, and he can’t discover an out there, reasonably priced wheelchair accessible residence within the metropolis. “It’s not like I’m not searching for a spot to reside, there simply aren’t any locations out there,” he stated. His son’s residence lacks the lodging Hansborough wants to have the ability to reside with him.
Concern of being compelled out of his residence, with HUD turning its again on him, plagues him. “I’ve by no means lived on the road. I’ve by no means been homeless. I’ve all the time had a roof over my head,” he stated. “It simply scares the crap out of me. It retains me up at night time.”
There are few locations for him to show with HUD rejecting civil rights enforcement. Missouri’s protections towards housing discrimination fall below the federal authorities’s minimal normal, so Hansbrough isn’t possible to have the ability to safe justice by means of the state. He may carry his personal lawsuit in courtroom, however litigation is expensive and time consuming. And it’s tough to get a lawyer to take most truthful housing circumstances; they often don’t have a number of damages to be recovered, making them financially untenable. Pursuing a case with out a lawyer, in the meantime, is “going to be extraordinarily tough,” Samberg-Champion stated.
“We’re the one place the place somebody can get free authorized assist by consultants who’re required to carry the case,” Osadebe stated. With out HUD, “You’re simply by yourself.”
Hansbrough is fortunate to have Jackson by his facet; many individuals go to HUD with out legal professionals and will now should file claims with state businesses or within the courts by themselves.
However with HUD abdicating duty for implementing truthful housing legal guidelines, Hansbrough feels deserted. “I’m so disenchanted in HUD. I anticipated higher of them,” Hansbrough stated. “It hurts quite a bit.”
Over the previous 12 months you’ve learn Nation writers like Elie Mystal, Kaveh Akbar, John Nichols, Joan Walsh, Bryce Covert, Dave Zirin, Jeet Heer, Michael T. Klare, Katha Pollitt, Amy Littlefield, Gregg Gonsalves, and Sasha Abramsky tackle the Trump household’s corruption, set the file straight about Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s catastrophic Make America Wholesome Once more motion, survey the fallout and human value of the DOGE wrecking ball, anticipate the Supreme Court docket’s harmful antidemocratic rulings, and amplify profitable ways of resistance on the streets and in Congress.
We publish these tales as a result of when members of our communities are being kidnapped, family debt is climbing, and AI information facilities are inflicting water and electrical energy shortages, we’ve got an obligation as journalists to do all we are able to to tell the general public.
In 2026, our intention is to do greater than ever earlier than—however we’d like your help to make that occur.
By December 31, a beneficiant donor will match all donations as much as $75,000. That implies that your contribution will likely be doubled, greenback for greenback. If we hit the complete match, we’ll be beginning 2026 with $150,000 to spend money on the tales that influence actual individuals’s lives—the sorts of tales that billionaire-owned, corporate-backed shops aren’t overlaying.
Along with your help, our staff will publish main tales that the president and his allies received’t need you to learn. We’ll cowl the rising military-tech industrial complicated and issues of warfare, peace, and surveillance, in addition to the affordability disaster, starvation, housing, healthcare, the setting, assaults on reproductive rights, and far more. On the similar time, we’ll think about options to Trumpian rule and uplift efforts to create a greater world, right here and now.
Whereas your reward has twice the influence, I’m asking you to support The Nation with a donation as we speak. You’ll empower the journalists, editors, and fact-checkers finest geared up to carry this authoritarian administration to account.
I hope you received’t miss this second—donate to The Nation as we speak.
Onward,
Katrina vanden Heuvel
Editor and writer, The Nation
Extra from The Nation
This week’s “Elie v. US” explores the authoritarian risk beneath Trump’s bonuses for navy households. Plus, a case for eliminating the Second Modification.
Trump and his MAGA allies need individuals like Omar to fade from this nation—they usually hate her for refusing to take action.
The outgoing New York Metropolis comptroller discusses governing on the left, his run for Congress, and why housing and affordability ought to outline the subsequent Democratic battle.
