The destructive force that’s DOGE nonetheless in some way manages to exist, regardless of it not being (relying on which declare is made and when) an official federal company and/or overseen by anybody particularly identifiable as the top of DOGE.
Till just lately, everybody — together with Donald Trump — knew (and stated as a lot in public) that DOGE was each a authorities company and headed by Elon Musk. When the lawsuits began flying, the backtracking started by the administration, which apparently thought it may cowl its tracks by strolling backwards in its golf-cleated clown reveals.
Trump’s love for DOGE has managed to undercut the protections DOGE hoped it could be capable to avail itself of when the FOIA requests started pouring in and the invention calls for began hitting federal dockets.
The administration is now making an attempt a Hail Mary play, albeit one which hails Thomas and Alito (and probably, Roberts), fairly than the patron saint it’s named after. Given the make-up of this present courtroom, it in all probability has a much better likelihood of success than merely hurling the ball into the air and hoping somebody on their very own staff manages to come back down with it. (And, certainly, it has already scored a temporary stay, because of an emergency order issued by Chief Justice John Roberts.)
Residents for Duty and Ethics in Washington (CREW) has been suing DOGE ever because it rejected its FOIA requests for the company’s operational paperwork. The Trump Administration is now combating again, albeit with no less than one hand inadvertently tied behind its again, as Josh Gerstein and Kyle Cheney report for Politico:
The Justice Division filed an emergency appeal Wednesday urging the excessive courtroom to place a maintain on a decide’s orders giving a watchdog group entry to paperwork detailing firings, grant terminations and different actions proposed by the so-called Division of Authorities Effectivity, which was overseen by Tesla and SpaceX founder Elon Musk.
Solicitor Normal John Sauer can be asking the Supreme Court docket to dam a deposition of the obscure official the Trump administration has recognized because the chief of the budget-cutting drive: DOGE administrator Amy Gleason.
The crux of the administration’s opacity argument [PDF] is that this: DOGE is nothing greater than an advisory entity that lacks the facility to make impartial selections. Clearly, all the things about DOGE says in any other case, because it has propelled large staffing and funding cuts throughout a number of companies, participated in extraordinarily careless (and possibly illegal) knowledge exfiltration, and executed just about whatever it wants because it materialized because the barely-sentient moist dream of a man who insists on wearing a baseball cap to each Oval Workplace assembly.
However that has been undercut by Trump himself, who has said the company undoubtedly can do all the things the administration is now claiming in courtroom it can’t do, in addition to thrown somebody underneath the DOGE bus to behave because the recipient for the unfavourable consideration (and FOIA requests, and deposition calls for) Trump managed to efficiently defend his fascist-saluting man-child from since his return to the Oval Workplace.
This hassle has been brewing for just a few months:
U.S. District Decide Christopher Cooper discovered there have been robust indications that DOGE was really directing cuts and layoffs at quite a few federal companies. That substantive operational position suggests DOGE’s actions fall underneath the Freedom of Data Act, the decide wrote.
Now {that a} decide is saying stuff we’ve all been in a position to clearly observe since DOGE’s inception, the administration now needs the Supreme Court docket to declare that the general public (and a number of litigants) shouldn’t be allowed to consider their very own eyes.
Making issues worse for the administration’s anti-transparency efforts is the truth that it has lastly determined to place somebody’s identify on the highest of the division’s letterhead: DOGE administrator Amy Gleason. (From what’s known about Gleason, it appears clear she’s getting used to catch bullets meant for Trump/Musk, fairly than really direct DOGE operations.)
Whereas this may in all probability hold Musk and his mouth out of courtroom, it does make it clear that DOGE not solely acts by itself impulses (fairly than simply supply mass termination “steering”) however that somebody will in the end must reply questions on DOGE’s actions in courtroom, ought to discovery requests handle to safe some depositions.
Clearly, the conventional courtroom processes and determinations in litigation towards DOGE can’t be allowed to face. That’s why the administration needs the judges it purchased to present it a free cross on destroying the federal authorities whereas concurrently stopping the general public from studying something extra concerning the salt-the-earth ways being spearheaded by DOGE. And it actually doesn’t matter whose identify is presently on the prime of the org chart by way of destruction. Nevertheless it does matter with regards to FOIA litigation and the administration’s insistence DOGE is restricted to easily suggesting strikes the administration would possibly wish to make.
There’s no telling how this desperation transfer will work out. The Supreme Court docket has performed each side of the encroaching fascism line in latest weeks, giving Trump some free passes whereas sometimes shutting down the administration’s efforts to fade constitutional rights into the anti-immigration cornfield.
Let’s hope this may find yourself being one of many latter. What’s already recognized about DOGE and its operations is extraordinarily disturbing. Maybe the publicity of extra inside data will assist extra folks understand the federal government they selected to elect is actively attempting to destroy most of the issues they nonetheless maintain expensive and propel some opposition from residents who by no means thought they’d be #NeverTrump. We will solely hope.
Trump Administration Tells Supreme Court DOGE Can’t Be FOIAed
Extra Legislation-Associated Tales From Techdirt:
RFK Jr.’s MAHA Report Cites Studies That Don’t Seem To Exist, Misinterprets Others
Fifth Circuit: Fuck It, The Censors Can Control Public Libraries
Senator Wyden: U.S. Wireless Carriers Fail Utterly To Inform Consumers (Or Senators) About Government Surveillance
