By Michael E. Flowers
In a June 2023 essay entitled “Civics: Who Will Educate Them?,” U.S. District Decide Curtis L. Collier of the Jap District of Tennessee made the next assertion in regards to the crucial significance of efficient civics schooling for all U.S. residents: “An vital element of being a superb citizen is being an knowledgeable and educated citizen. Meaning having a working information of how our authorities is structured, the way it features, the function of the completely different branches of presidency, their separate powers, the branches’ obligations and the restrictions on their powers. With out such information, it’s almost unimaginable for us to meet our duties or correctly train our privileges as residents.”
I agree with Decide Collier and stay satisfied we have now to proceed to position emphasis on civic schooling. Thomas Jefferson, the third U.S. president, reached this similar conclusion when he stated, “An knowledgeable citizenry is on the coronary heart of a dynamic democracy.”
As you could recall from historical past, when Benjamin Franklin, who was one of many signers of the Declaration of Independence, was as soon as requested what sort of presidency the Constitutional Conference adopted, his cautionary response was, “A republic, in the event you can hold it.” I believe Benjamin Franklin was giving us a warning that to keep up a republic, its ideas should be understood and deliberately handed alongside to every succeeding era.
One of many essential ideas supporting our republic is our adherence to the robust conviction that we’re a rustic that’s dominated by duly enacted legal guidelines and never by the whims of males or girls. The shorthand expression for this concept is that our nation helps the rule of regulation.
Whereas this sounds commendable, the query is will we all have a shared understanding of what it means to say we assist the rule of regulation? The phrase is used broadly within the media, by our elected officers and members of most of the people. However I’m not persuaded that after we enter right into a dialogue in regards to the state of the rule of regulation in our nation, all of us outline this idea the identical means.
I imagine we’re in an vital teachable second the place legal professionals can prepared the ground to creating positive our fellow residents have a productive understanding of what it means to say we’re a rustic that helps the rule of regulation.
I’d provide to your consideration the definition of the rule of regulation developed by the World Justice Challenge. For these of you who should not acquainted with this group, the World Justice Challenge is an impartial, nonprofit, multidisciplinary group that has for almost 20 years been working to create information, construct consciousness and stimulate motion to advance the rule of regulation right here at dwelling and worldwide. Its founders and present board members embody a number of the main legal professionals within the U.S. and from different international locations.
The next is the definition of the rule of regulation that has been developed and adopted by the World Justice Challenge: “The rule of regulation is a sturdy system of legal guidelines, establishments, norms and neighborhood dedication that delivers 4 common ideas: (1) accountability, (2) simply regulation, (3) open authorities and (4) accessible and neutral justice.”
So what do these 4 ideas actually imply?
• First, accountability: The federal government, in addition to personal actors, are accountable below the regulation.
• After we say “simply regulation”: The regulation is obvious, publicized and secure and is utilized evenly. It ensures human rights, in addition to rights which might be vital to the enterprise neighborhood, reminiscent of property, contract and procedural rights.
• By way of “open authorities”: The processes by which the regulation is adopted, administered, adjudicated and enforced are accessible, honest and environment friendly.
• And eventually, accessible and neutral justice: Justice is delivered well timed by competent, moral and impartial representatives and neutrals who’re themselves accessible, have ample sources, and replicate the make-up of the communities they serve.
What I’d emphasize about these 4 ideas of the rule of regulation that type the definition of the rule of regulation utilized by the World Justice Challenge is that these common ideas should not partisan ideas. They’re mainstream American ideas that, when defined, I’d anticipate would garner widespread acceptance and assist amongst most audiences.
I imagine we can higher choose what’s or will not be in line with the rule of regulation if we begin our evaluation utilizing a shared definition of this crucial pillar on which our society is constructed.
My cost to myself and to my colleagues within the authorized occupation is to hunt alternatives to have significant conversations with our work colleagues, our neighbors and our members of the family about what’s their understanding of the rule of regulation. I’m assured these conversations might be extra impactful if they’re based mostly on a shared conceptual framework round what is supposed by the rule of regulation.
Because the management of the World Justice Challenge reminds us, irrespective of who we’re or the place we reside on this nation, the rule of regulation impacts us all. It’s the basis for communities of justice, alternative and peace. The rule of regulation underpins financial improvement, accountable authorities and respect for basic human rights, all of which we wish for ourselves and for individuals who will observe us.
Michael E. Flowers is a member of Steptoe & Johnson, the place he practices basic company and business actual property regulation inside the regulation agency’s enterprise regulation division. He’s additionally the agency’s director of range and inclusion. Flowers is a former chair of the ABA Enterprise Legislation Part and a former member of the ABA Board of Governors and the Ohio State Bar Affiliation’s board of governors. He presently serves on the ABA Cornerstones of Democracy Fee and is a member of the ABA Home of Delegates representing the Ohio State Bar Affiliation.
ABAJournal.com is accepting queries for authentic, considerate, nonpromotional articles and commentary by unpaid contributors to run within the Your Voice part. Particulars and submission pointers are posted at “Your Submissions, Your Voice.”
This column displays the opinions of the writer and never essentially the views of the ABA Journal—or the American Bar Affiliation.
