The brand new editor in chief at CBS Information has proven she’s not merely stupendously unqualified—she’s ideologically against the observe of excellent journalism.
CBS Information editor in chief Bari Weiss hosts a city corridor with Erika Kirk on December 10.
(Michele Crowe / CBS Information through Getty Photographs)
The mega-rich have at all times been prepared to rent, promote, and fund individuals prepared to unquestioningly run interference for his or her pursuits whereas making them really feel like their near-pathological selfishness, hoarding of cash and energy, and whole disregard for the general public curiosity is someway morally justifiable. CBS Information editor in chief Bari Weiss is just one other in an extended line of feckless water carriers for the 1 %.
Which 1-percenters, you ask? Effectively, it’s exhausting to inform; there are such a lot of of them. A latest New York magazine article outlining Weiss’s reputation with leisure moguls and celebrities who’re very, very indignant about wokeness (however don’t need to be thought of bigots, you perceive) is so rife with the names of A-list billionaires and centi-millionaires that I believe I went up a tax bracket simply by studying it. Associates, supporters, and buyers embrace Lloyd Blankenfein, Howard Schultz, Jeff Bezos, Brian Grazer, Herb Allen III, and an assortment of different individuals who assume pronouns in e-mail signatures are embarrassing however “Chief Happiness Officer” is just not. They consider in empathy and compassion as rhetorical wrappers for company exercise however in the actual world have none for susceptible individuals except it comes with a tax write-off.
Weiss’s latest patron is David Ellison, the CEO of Paramount Skydance, who has bought The Free Press, her center-right commentary Substack that’s dedicated to “liberal ideas of free speech and open inquiry” so long as the open inquiries match neatly into a skinny slice of the center-to-center-right continuum. As a part of the deal, Weiss, a commentator with no expertise working a broadcast newsroom, was made the editor in chief of CBS Information.
David Ellison and his father, Larry, are allies of and monetary supporters of Donald Trump. In any atypical newsroom, this could represent a battle of curiosity that may necessitate the development of moral firewalls designed to stop protection of the presidency from being unduly influenced by these relationships. Ellison the youthful has finished the other: Weiss is reporting on to him reasonably than any of the information executives at CBS. Removed from working inside a firewall, Weiss is a conduit.
This turned particularly clear on Sunday, when she pulled a 60 Minutes report about Venezuelan males whom the Trump White Home has deported to El Salvador’s infamous Terrorism Confinement Middle (CECOT) mega jail. Weiss justified her determination on the grounds that the section didn’t characteristic a remark from the White Home (it did notice that the White Home had elected to not give a remark when the reporters on the piece requested one, which is all of the due diligence required). 60 Minutes correspondent Sharyn Alfonsi mentioned in an e-mail to colleagues, “Our story was screened 5 occasions and cleared by each CBS attorneys and Requirements and Practices. It’s factually right. In my opinion, pulling it now, after each rigorous inside examine has been met, is just not an editorial determination, it’s a political one.”
Weiss claims this isn’t true, in fact. “Holding tales that aren’t prepared for no matter motive—that they lack ample context, say, or that they’re lacking important voices—occurs on daily basis in each newsroom.”
Present Situation
I’ve written for a lot of completely different newsrooms and run newsrooms myself. “Screened 5 occasions and cleared by attorneys and Requirements and Practices” is a stage of assessment that exceeds any I’ve skilled, together with at main newsrooms like The New York Instances and The Washington Publish. The concept the entire events concerned—lots of whom are closely legal responsibility oriented—missed one thing that Bari Weiss didn’t strains credulity, particularly given Weiss’s traditionally lax reporting requirements for herself.
The funniest and mercifully lowest-stakes instance of Weiss’s personal anemic requirements of editorial assessment comes from Weiss’s Free Press investigation—and I exploit the phrase “investigation” very loosely—of the resignation of a librarian named Jodi Shaw from Smith Faculty. Shaw had alleged that she skilled “reverse racism” after the college wouldn’t enable her, a white girl, to make a presentation at a division assembly in a rap format. Weiss’s major beat on the time was producing an countless collection of articles claiming that involved residents and personal college college students frequently known as her to complain about leftist overreach on their well-appointed campuses. Weiss wrote that each day, “I get telephone calls from anxious Individuals complaining about an ideology that desires to drag all of us into the previous. I get calls from dad and mom telling me concerning the damaging issues being taught in faculties: so-called antiracist packages that urge kids to obsess on the colour of their pores and skin. I get calls from individuals working in company America pressured to go to trainings through which they study that they carry collective, race-based guilt—or profit from collective, race-based advantage.”
Once I got here throughout this overwrought testimonial, I initially assumed that it was rooted in a primary misunderstanding. Maybe Weiss had latched herself onto Shaw’s plight beneath the misapprehension {that a} rapped presentation that promised to be exceedingly awkward—and meant not for comparatively powerless college students or company underlings however for Shaw’s administrative friends—was someway a constitutionally protected mode of self-expression. And possibly Shaw, who claimed to Weiss that she was a lifelong liberal, which Weiss took at face worth and didn’t query, merely didn’t perceive that rapping in a piece assembly was… unorthodox? Unprofessional? As I wrote at the time, “No, [Ms. Shaw], you can’t rap your presentation, and neither are you able to set it to Sondheim, or Twitch it whereas enjoying Name of Responsibility, or ship it as an summary efficiency titled The Scholar Help Coordinator Is Current.”
However right here I did one thing Weiss didn’t appear to have any inclination to do: I picked up the telephone. And in contrast to Weiss’s telephone, which she claims is at all times ringing with aggrieved wealthy individuals horrified by wokeness, my telephone makes outbound calls. So I known as, amongst different locations, Smith Faculty. Which refuted her total story. I picked up some sources alongside the way in which who instructed me Shaw had been kicked out of an alumni group for causes that positively contradict her claims to have been a lifelong liberal, and a path of digital posts by Shaw herself railing towards social justice.
I can not emphasize this strongly sufficient: This was the bottom doable effort I may make to take a look at this story, and it was nonetheless too excessive a bar for Bari Weiss. (This didn’t cease her from doing this once more. Should you’re feeling masochistic, you may examine a really indignant dad at Manhattan’s unique Brearly prep college here.)
In different phrases, I discover it exhausting to consider that Weiss has instantly become a crackerjack reporter and editor, and is able to working a storied newsroom that always does complicated investigative reporting. The rapping librarian story occurred simply 4 years in the past, in any case.
And I discover it totally implausible that the 60 Minutes section was pulled as a result of there was one thing that a whole crew of skilled reporters and producers, many legal professionals, and lots of standards-and-practices people who find themselves employed particularly to carry tales on the slightest indication that they is likely to be incomplete or inaccurate, missed. Extra possible, she is simply doing what she at all times does: producing a line of propaganda masquerading as information protection that serves the curiosity of her patrons—on this case, David Ellison, whose pursuits are served by defending Donald Trump. (In anticipation of Ellison’s buyout, CBS executives thought it advisable to sign their MAGA fealty by settling a meritless lawsuit Trump had introduced towards 60 Minutes protesting their edits of an election-season interview with Kamala Harris; that act of brazen capitulation now appears just like the operatic overture to Weiss’s quisling tour on the helm of the newsmagazine present.)
The attraction of journalism—for good journalists—is serving the general public curiosity by, amongst different issues, holding individuals in energy accountable. It’s additionally true that very wealthy and influential individuals personal many information organizations, which instills an inherent pressure at their foundations—which is why the firewalls that Weiss appears decided to steamroll have lengthy been in place. The job of an editor in chief is, amongst different issues, to bolster these firewalls. Weiss was not employed despite her unwillingness to do this however due to it.
Good journalists punch up; Weiss punches down. There isn’t any susceptible inhabitants she doesn’t blame for his or her immiseration, and when she talks about “open inquiry,” her record of verboten viewpoints consists of the affirmation of the humanity of Palestinians and the denunciation of the continuing genocide in Gaza, any opposition to a free market (although she doesn’t appear to have a cloth downside with tariffs and different anti-market insurance policies in the event that they’re coming from the Trump administration), along with any suggestion that girls and minorities face systemic discrimination, or that faith is just not an unalloyed good. She says she is a liberal within the classical sense of selling free markets and upbraiding authorities interference within the lives of people. She largely disowns the fashionable social-democratic model of liberal politics, although she is going to opportunistically invoke it in passing by reminding individuals she was a Hillary Clinton supporter and that she’s homosexual, truly. In different phrases, Weiss, like lots of her fire-breathing anti-woke allies, tends to wield the time period “liberal” within the intellectually dishonest manner favored among the many antidemocratic and authoritarian-minded individuals who insist “we’re not a democracy, we’re a republic.”
In a speech to the Federalist Society in 2023, she mentioned, “In recognizing allies, I’ll be an instance. I’m a homosexual girl who’s reasonably pro-choice. I do know there are some on this room who don’t consider my marriage ought to have been authorized. And that’s okay, as a result of we’re all Individuals who need decrease taxes.” By itself, this assertion is worthy of a spit take, however its broader context speaks volumes concerning the type of political-cum-journalistic agenda Weiss endorses. She went on to supply a high-imperialist account of the righteous response to the October 7 assaults that positioned the room stuffed with right-wing ideologues in her viewers on the vanguard of what she known as a civilizational battle:
The distinction between 9/11 and 10/7 was that the disaster of 10/7 was adopted, on October 8, by a distinct form of disaster. An ethical and religious disaster that was on full show all through the West earlier than the our bodies of these women and men and kids had even been recognized.
Individuals poured into the streets of our capital cities to have fun the slaughter.
In Sydney, crowds gathered on the Sydney Opera Home cheering “gasoline the Jews.” Individuals rejoiced on the streets of Berlin and London and Toronto and New York.
Then got here BLM Chicago utilizing the paraglider—a logo of mass loss of life—as a logo of freedom. Then got here posters throughout our campuses calling for Israel to burn. Then got here our personal places of work in New York Metropolis being vandalized with “Fuck Jews” and “Fuck Israel.” Then got here Harvard’s process drive to create secure areas for pro-Hamas college students.
As they are saying on the Web, of all of the issues that didn’t occur, this didn’t occur essentially the most. The fabulism on show right here is as unhealthy or worse than Donald Trump’s claiming that he noticed Muslims celebrating 9/11 from a rooftop in New Jersey. These form of statements weren’t an aberration for Weiss, both; they’re claims she has repeated incessantly within the aftermath of the October 7 assaults.
Well-liked
“swipe left under to view extra authors”Swipe →
In any regular newsroom, anybody presenting as reality Islamophobic city legends like these could be disqualified from newsgathering, and presumably referred to a very good therapist. However with Ellison and Weiss overseeing the information operations of the community, CBS might now not be within the information enterprise—particularly if something that the newsroom produces is at all times topic to a pocket veto from both of them in defiance of the canons of editorial assessment. And if the destiny of the CECOT section is any indication, the upper the stakes are, the likelier it will likely be {that a} story meets with suppression from on excessive.
In Weiss, Ellison and Trump have discovered a prepared enabler and compensated her richly. The wealthy and highly effective already sleep soundly in comparison with the remainder of us. And to evaluate by Weiss’s monitor document to this point, her tenure at CBS will probably be one lengthy and soothing lullaby for hoarders of energy and wealth. They are going to be beguiled by a gentle stream of comforting lies that forged susceptible Individuals as villains and the billionaire class as courageous and righteous defenders of open debate–that means, in fact, the form of debate they need to see parroted by designated courtiers like Bari Weiss.
Over the previous yr you’ve learn Nation writers like Elie Mystal, Kaveh Akbar, John Nichols, Joan Walsh, Bryce Covert, Dave Zirin, Jeet Heer, Michael T. Klare, Katha Pollitt, Amy Littlefield, Gregg Gonsalves, and Sasha Abramsky tackle the Trump household’s corruption, set the document straight about Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s catastrophic Make America Wholesome Once more motion, survey the fallout and human price of the DOGE wrecking ball, anticipate the Supreme Courtroom’s harmful antidemocratic rulings, and amplify profitable ways of resistance on the streets and in Congress.
We publish these tales as a result of when members of our communities are being kidnapped, family debt is climbing, and AI information facilities are inflicting water and electrical energy shortages, we have now an obligation as journalists to do all we are able to to tell the general public.
In 2026, our purpose is to do greater than ever earlier than—however we’d like your assist to make that occur.
Via December 31, a beneficiant donor will match all donations as much as $75,000. That implies that your contribution will probably be doubled, greenback for greenback. If we hit the complete match, we’ll be beginning 2026 with $150,000 to put money into the tales that impression actual individuals’s lives—the sorts of tales that billionaire-owned, corporate-backed shops aren’t masking.
Along with your assist, our crew will publish main tales that the president and his allies received’t need you to learn. We’ll cowl the rising military-tech industrial complicated and issues of battle, peace, and surveillance, in addition to the affordability disaster, starvation, housing, healthcare, the atmosphere, assaults on reproductive rights, and far more. On the similar time, we’ll think about options to Trumpian rule and uplift efforts to create a greater world, right here and now.
Whereas your present has twice the impression, I’m asking you to support The Nation with a donation at the moment. You’ll empower the journalists, editors, and fact-checkers greatest geared up to carry this authoritarian administration to account.
I hope you received’t miss this second—donate to The Nation at the moment.
Onward,
Katrina vanden Heuvel
Editor and writer, The Nation
Extra from The Nation
The ballroom and his different proposed constructing initiatives are many issues, however they don’t seem to be precisely works of structure.
David Landes argues that cell telephones signify an remoted life whereas Kimberly Hassel blames the loneliness disaster on a society unable to assist or shield its youth.
I spent six months with a flip telephone. I realized {that a} extra aware technological future would require far more than simply unplugging.
In 1994, the author Leslie Marmon Silko wrote a bit for The Nation warning of a daunting new immigration regime.
