The most effective counter to Trump’s authoritarianism is a renewed dedication to safe full consultant democracy in Washington.
Members of the Nationwide Guard patrol on the Nationwide Mall on August 26, 2025 in Washington, DC.
(Alex Wong / Getty Pictures)
The District of Columbia is just not a state. It’s the legally enigmatic, underrepresented, and formally disempowered creation of a federal authorities that has a historical past of neglecting the wants and the potential of the nation’s capital metropolis. Now Donald Trump has taken full benefit of this circumstance to flood Washington with closely armed troopers and masked federal brokers.
Trump acknowledges that his transfer to militarize legislation enforcement in DC has unsettled Individuals. “Already they’re saying, ‘He’s a dictator,’” Trump said final week, after the navy surge started. The president claimed that he was simply attempting to battle an out-of-control crime wave. “The place goes to hell and we’ve bought to cease it,” he introduced. “So as a substitute of claiming ‘He’s a dictator,’ they need to say, ‘We’re going to affix him and make Washington protected.’”
However Trump’s crime declare is improper. “There may be not against the law disaster in DC,” Rosa Brooks, a former DC Metropolitan reserve police officer who now teaches at Georgetown Regulation Faculty, told NPR. Brooks decried the president’s authoritarian overreach, saying, “That is police state territory, banana republic police state territory.”
Sadly, there’s a appreciable historical past of federal administrations and Republican congresses coming into “banana republic police state territory” with regards to DC.
Frederick Douglass acknowledged that there was a disaster of democracy within the nation’s capital 135 years in the past. The good abolitionist and social reformer, who taught that “energy concedes nothing and not using a demand. It by no means did and it by no means will,” was as forward of his time when it got here to DC as he was in so many different areas. He spent the final years of his life working with a pioneering voting rights group, the District Suffrage Petition Association, to deliver the promise and the safety of democracy to DC.
Douglass attended the group’s conferences and rallies, and requested, “What have the individuals of the district completed that they need to be excluded from the privileges of the poll field?”
Present Difficulty
A number of of the democratic reforms that Douglass advocated for through the course of his exceptional lifetime have been achieved within the century after his loss of life. Washington immediately has an elected mayor and metropolis council, in addition to the flexibility to forged ballots (and select electors) in presidential elections.
But, 130 years after Douglass died, the residents of the District of Columbia are nonetheless blocked from electing voting members of Congress.
The denial of the total franchise to residents of the nation’s capital metropolis is only one instance of the patchwork strategy to suffrage in america, the place Individuals who stay in commonwealths, territories, and possessions lack full representation rights in Congress and, in most situations, the fitting to vote for president. Even within the states, voting rights are ill-defined, and the Voting Rights Act, already so weakened by the Supreme Court docket, is beneath additional authorized assault—as the present gerrymandering push by Trump-aligned Texas Republicans so amply illustrates.
But the District of Columbia has maybe essentially the most complicated relationship with voting rights of any US jurisdiction. Whereas district residents can vote in presidential elections, they don’t have the fitting to elect voting representatives to the Home or Senate. DC Delegate Eleanor Holmes Norton, the veteran civil rights activist who campaigned for a few years for the location of the seven-foot-tall Douglass statue that now stands within the US Capitol, recalled when it was dedicated a dozen years in the past, “There was too little recognition that as a District of Columbia resident, three Republican presidents appointed Douglass to a few native posts: to what was then the higher chamber of the DC Council, a part of the home-rule authorities given the district by the Republican Congress and president throughout Reconstruction, as DC recorder of deeds and as US marshal for the native and federal courts. Who knew that Douglass misplaced the Republican nomination for delegate to the US Home of Representatives?”
Norton and others know that immediately, although DC has an elected native authorities, the ability of that authorities—and, thus, of Washington residents to find out their very own affairs—has usually been constrained by Republican Congresses. And it’s now being overridden by an authoritarian Republican president.
Residents of the district—which has a inhabitants bigger than Vermont’s and Wyoming’s—have organized, campaigned, and petitioned for statehood for many years.
Fashionable
“swipe left under to view extra authors”Swipe →
However the reason for statehood—and fundamental democratic respect—has been thwarted because the days when members of Congress refused the request of the good radical senator from South Dakota, Richard F. Pettigrew, who urged after the loss of life of Douglass in 1895 “that out of respect to his reminiscence his stays be permitted to lie in state within the rotunda of the Nationwide Capitol between the hours of 10 a.m. and 4 p.m. on tomorrow.”
At present, congressional Republicans type the first barrier to DC statehood. They like to notice that Douglass was a Republican. However that was within the day when Douglass noticed the GOP as a progressive drive that demanded the enlargement of the franchise.
In latest a long time, the Democratic Occasion has made the demand a normal a part of its platform. However, too incessantly, Democrats have completed so in an unfocused and halfhearted method. What’s been lacking is a way of urgency.
Trump’s militarization of policing within the metropolis establishes that urgency, now and into the longer term. Whereas a Trump-aligned Republican Congress is just not going to do the fitting factor, Democrats should make it clear that—as a part of the broader voting rights renaissance that should observe the Trump years—DC statehood will prime their agenda.
The dream of voting rights has been deferred because the days when Douglass wrote of the district as “the one spot the place there is no such thing as a authorities for the individuals, of the individuals and by the individuals. Its residents undergo rulers whom they don’t have any selection in choosing. They obey legal guidelines which they’d no voice in making.”
If the lengthy arc of the ethical universe bends towards justice, because the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr. preached in his lifetime, then certainly the legacy of this terrible second for American democracy have to be DC statehood.
On this second of disaster, we want a unified, progressive opposition to Donald Trump.
We’re beginning to see one take form within the streets and at poll bins throughout the nation: from New York Metropolis mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani’s marketing campaign targeted on affordability, to communities defending their neighbors from ICE, to the senators opposing arms shipments to Israel.
The Democratic Occasion has an pressing option to make: Will it embrace a politics that’s principled and common, or will it proceed to insist on dropping elections with the out-of-touch elites and consultants that bought us right here?
At The Nation, we all know which aspect we’re on. Day by day, we make the case for a extra democratic and equal world by championing progressive leaders, lifting up actions combating for justice, and exposing the oligarchs and firms profiting on the expense of us all. Our unbiased journalism informs and empowers progressives throughout the nation and helps deliver this politics to new readers prepared to affix the battle.
We want your assist to proceed this work. Will you donate to assist The Nation’s unbiased journalism? Each contribution goes to our award-winning reporting, evaluation, and commentary.
Thanks for serving to us tackle Trump and construct the simply society we all know is feasible.
Sincerely,
Bhaskar Sunkara
President, The Nation
Extra from The Nation
The president’s focusing on the Federal Reserve governor over a technicality is blatantly politically motivated.
Freedom of expression is a cornerstone of democracy, and any try to suppress it have to be resisted. This art work by Felipe Galindo Feggo, printed broadly, has been singled out o…
Profitable in November isn’t sufficient. A Mayor Mamdani will want a mass motion behind him to beat an institution that wishes to crush him.
Trans individuals signed as much as danger loss of life for a rustic they properly knew would seemingly by no means return the favor. And now the federal government is attempting to make their lives hell.
The loss of life toll in Gaza exceeds 63,000. Each day bombings, together with deliberate mass hunger and displacement by Israeli forces, present no indicators of stopping.
