It’s a giant deal that Republicans in Indiana’s state Senate final week squashed President Trump’s calls for for a gerrymandered US Home map that will have awarded the GOP a 9–0 congressional delegation within the state.
Sure, the remaining map remains to be a GOP gerrymander. It ensures Republicans seven secure seats, which they received in 2024 by a median of 30 share factors, regardless of netting simply 58 % of the statewide vote. A extra balanced map would come with as many as 4 districts inside believable attain of Democratic candidates.
And sure, all through the remainder of the nation, Republicans keep the higher hand throughout this unprecedented mid-decade redistricting battle. Maybe most consequentially, the GOP supermajority on the US Supreme Court docket may have the deciding vote when it guidelines on a voting rights case from Louisiana, maybe as quickly as subsequent month.
Nobody ought to really feel reassured on the chance that John Roberts can award the GOP a near-unbreakable grip on the Home just by doing two of his favourite issues: rendering the Voting Rights Act unworkable and declaring that the way in which to finish racial discrimination is to cease discrimination in opposition to white folks.
However, let’s be allowed a quick Mr. Smith second. Authoritarianism thrives amid cowardice and worry. It depends on the bended knee from those that know higher, whether or not members of Congress, the boards of Ivy League universities, companions at Paul, Weiss and Kirkland & Ellis, or the trembling overlords of CBS and ABC,
The stiffened backbone from Indiana’s Senate Republicans needs to be celebrated as that uncommon second by which Trump’s personal celebration stated no. They defied a forceful and unrelenting marketing campaign of MAGA intimidation.
Vice President JD Vance arm-twisted Hoosier state legislators twice in individual. The Membership for Progress invested part of its seven-figure budget to proceed churning out GOP gerrymanders in a digital strain marketing campaign. At the least 11 lawmakers had been subjected to bomb threats or swatting incidents at their houses. US Senator Jim Banks supplied the unassailable logic that the 9–0 map was “the least that we will do” as a result of “they killed Charlie Kirk.” Then as Thursday’s vote drew close to, the Heritage Foundation revealed that Trump threatened to chop off all federal funding to Indiana—“Roads won’t be paved. Guard bases will shut. Main tasks will cease”—if lawmakers didn’t rubber-stamp the gerrymander.
Indiana Republicans nonetheless stated no. A majority of the GOP caucus joined each Senate Democrat in shutting down this egregious partisan energy play.
That is an sudden growth within the gerrymandering armageddon that can possible decide which celebration controls the Home after the 2026 midterms—a no-holds-barred energy seize in state legislatures that to this point, has largely gone the Republicans method.
The scoreboard will proceed to fluctuate as extra state legislatures and the courts weigh in. However right here’s a way of the place issues stand.
At this second, presuming that new maps in California and Texas counteract one another, Republicans have picked up two seats in Ohio, one in Missouri and one in North Carolina.
The massive prize on the desk stays Florida, the place Governor Ron DeSantis has advised he may flip as many as three to 5 Democratic seats with a brand new map.
There may be renewed chatter in Kansas a couple of January particular session to erase the Kansas Metropolis–space seat at present held by Democrat Sharice Davids. Some lawmakers in New Hampshire continue to push for a mid-decade redraw as nicely. The Club for Growth and Turning Point Action have put hundreds of thousands on the desk to strain lawmakers there and elsewhere.
The GOP has likely lost one seat in Utah. Voters there amended the state Structure in 2018 to ascertain a nonpartisan redistricting advisory fee. Republicans repealed it, then drew a 4–0 gerrymander. When a state courtroom discovered the legislature’s actions unconstitutional, the GOP tried to stonewall with one other 4–0 map. The courtroom—in a second of all-too-rare independence in a crimson state—stated no, and imposed a map of its personal. On this map, blue Salt Lake Metropolis can be favored to elect a Democrat. The Republican legislature continues to battle and pursue appeals.
It additionally stays doable that the Missouri gerrymander may come off the board. Missouri activists certified a veto initiative by handing over an astounding 305,000 signatures this month. They wanted to gather solely 110,000. Ordinarily, that will droop the legislature’s motion till voters have their say in a statewide initiative. Missouri’s secretary of state and legal professional basic, nonetheless, have departed from precedent and allowed the map to remain in place. State courts might want to resolve this dispute—although there could also be additional end-runs forward from the state’s deep-red authorized directors..
Democrats proceed to lack many viable choices for gerrymanders of their very own. Virginia appears most likely to try. Some lawmakers have talked powerful a couple of 10–1 map. That’s in all probability MSNBC fan fiction. It could require a statewide vote, and the state’s new redistricting fee handed simply with 65 % of the vote in 2020. Would a majority on this purple state actually approve handing Democrats 90 % of the Home delegation? In any wave yr, the present map would produce two extra Democratic seats, regardless.
New York’s state Structure makes a brand new map terribly unlikely earlier than 2028. Illinois lawmakers appear to grasp that the present 14–3 Democratic gerrymander in all probability maximizes the celebration’s good points. The Democratic state Senate chief in Maryland has refused to consider an 8–0 map that provides yet another blue seat. Oregon’s governor has additionally declined to think about an all-blue delegation. No motion appears possible from New Jersey. Some lawmakers and gubernatorial hopefuls in Colorado favor an effort to work round their state’s new fee, however that’s not viable earlier than 2028.
And but: As a result of Republicans didn’t take the 2 seats in Indiana, and, for the second, haven’t moved on Kansas, Kentucky, Nebraska, or New Hampshire, the state of play for Democrats will not be as dire because it appeared it may be simply a number of weeks in the past. Let’s say Florida finds three seats, and likewise that Kansas reconsiders and targets the Davids seat in January. Too many GOP lawmakers want to be governor in 2026, and this may be a simple technique to curry favor with the White Home. That’s a web of seven seats. Voters in these districts, in addition to within the affected Texas and California seats, would have their selections curtailed, but it surely wouldn’t put the Home past attain of the precise type of blue wave.
Just one group of Republicans may guarantee an hermetic set of GOP gerrymanders at this level: the conservative supermajority on the US Supreme Court docket. The Roberts courtroom may have the last word say over the 2026 midterms, because it has in so many different White Home initiatives in Ttrump’s authoritarian second time period. Again in October, the courtroom heard Louisiana v Callais. It is a problem to the constitutionality of Part 2 of the Voting Rights Act (VRA), and the usage of race to attract majority-minority districts in lined localities to guard minority communities that may in any other case don’t have any illustration in any respect.
The stakes are terribly excessive. Stacey Abrams’s Truthful Combat and Black Voters Matter Fund means that as many as 19 seats at present held largely by Black Democrats—in South Carolina, Georgia, Tennessee, Florida, Alabama, Louisiana, Mississippi and Missouri, amongst others—may very well be within the crosshairs. These VRA protections clarify, for instance, why Missouri Republicans focused the Kansas Metropolis district final fall moderately than St. Louis, which is roofed below the Act. It explains why North Carolina Republicans acted to redraw their map, however Alabama and Tennessee didn’t.
Standard
“swipe left beneath to view extra authors”Swipe →
If the courtroom suspends Part 2 in these states, a few of these districts may very well be wiped off the map early subsequent yr. This is able to devastate minority illustration throughout the South and sure return the variety of Black members from the affected states to Jim Crow–period ranges. And an anti–voting rights determination would in all chance hand most, if not all, of these seats to white conservatives.
The courtroom’s conservatives teed this case up. Chief Justice John Roberts has worked toward this goal since he arrived in Washington as a younger warrior in Ronald Reagan’s Division of Justice. Justice Brett Kavanaugh laid out the winning argument in a ruling on an earlier take a look at case. And when the courtroom wanted to supply much more help, it ordered the case reargued alongside particular constitutional traces.
Which is to say: Everyone knows what Roberts needs to do. The choice right here seems to be a foregone conclusion: The courtroom will possible go away the VRA intact in identify solely, whereas making all of it however unimaginable to make use of. The actual thriller is when will probably be introduced, and precisely how far it would go. By scheduling arguments for early October, the courtroom opened the doorways to a call as quickly as January. (Residents United, one other case the courtroom ordered reordered early in its 2009–10 time period, got here down in late January.) That may very well be quickly sufficient for some states to enact new maps forward of 2026. (The courtroom’s completely made-up Purcell precept that allegedly governs modifications to election legal guidelines forward of an election is not a legal standard however a political one, firmly nested in Roberts’s zone for calling balls and strikes, relying on who’s hitting and who’s pitching.)
That Roberts is a partisan par excellence is a settled query at this level. However he’s additionally a affected person partisan. He has waited 40 years for this victory. He would possibly nicely maintain out till March or April, making new maps extra possible for 2028 than 2026 (and possibly profitable reward from hollow-eyed op-ed boards for his knowledge and restraint). How partisan does he need to be earlier than the midterms? Is that this his high precedence? Or would he slow-walk this determination for the sake of upholding a unique growth of govt energy?
The midterms might depend on which John Roberts shapes the Callais opinion. Will it’s the regular incrementalist who bulldozes slowly on behalf of his workforce? Or will it’s the John Roberts pleased to permit his courtroom to do the unpopular soiled work on voting rights that many Republicans, resembling these in Indiana, nonetheless recoil from? Do not forget that the identical GOP Congress that confirmed Roberts additionally reauthorized the Voting Rights Act almost unanimously in 2006, safe within the data that the Republicans appointed for all times would deal with it for them.
A lot has been misplaced. Voters throughout Texas, California, Ohio, Missouri, and North Carolina will solid ballots in districts which can be dramatically much less honest, in elections the place the outcomes have largely been predetermined. Minority illustration may very well be endangered. The reform trigger has been set again and endangered because the events have raced towards the underside. And most of that is Roberts’s soiled legacy.
Democrats may very well be in a harder place. The trail to profitable again the Home, the almost definitely path to slowing Trump’s march to Hungarian-style aggressive autocracy, can be marginally harder if Indiana, Kansas, and Nebraska pushed extra seats into the GOP pile.
Nonetheless, that is no second for celebration. The midterms, the way forward for minority illustration, and even perhaps an everlasting Home majority that might final for cycles on finish is within the fingers of a chief justice who has been his celebration’s simplest strategist and tactician of the twenty first century. It’s lengthy been clear that John Roberts won’t save us. The uncomfortable query earlier than us is just how far, and how briskly, he needs to show again the clock.
Over the previous yr you’ve learn Nation writers like Elie Mystal, Kaveh Akbar, John Nichols, Joan Walsh, Bryce Covert, Dave Zirin, Jeet Heer, Michael T. Klare, Katha Pollitt, Amy Littlefield, Gregg Gonsalves, and Sasha Abramsky tackle the Trump household’s corruption, set the file straight about Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s catastrophic Make America Wholesome Once more motion, survey the fallout and human value of the DOGE wrecking ball, anticipate the Supreme Court docket’s harmful antidemocratic rulings, and amplify profitable techniques of resistance on the streets and in Congress.
We publish these tales as a result of when members of our communities are being kidnapped, family debt is climbing, and AI information facilities are inflicting water and electrical energy shortages, we’ve an obligation as journalists to do all we will to tell the general public.
In 2026, our intention is to do greater than ever earlier than—however we want your assist to make that occur.
By way of December 31, a beneficiant donor will match all donations as much as $75,000. That signifies that your contribution will probably be doubled, greenback for greenback. If we hit the total match, we’ll be beginning 2026 with $150,000 to put money into the tales that affect actual folks’s lives—the sorts of tales that billionaire-owned, corporate-backed retailers aren’t overlaying.
Together with your assist, our workforce will publish main tales that the president and his allies received’t need you to learn. We’ll cowl the rising military-tech industrial complicated and issues of battle, peace, and surveillance, in addition to the affordability disaster, starvation, housing, healthcare, the atmosphere, assaults on reproductive rights, and far more. On the similar time, we’ll think about alternate options to Trumpian rule and uplift efforts to create a greater world, right here and now.
Whereas your reward has twice the affect, I’m asking you to support The Nation with a donation right now. You’ll empower the journalists, editors, and fact-checkers finest geared up to carry this authoritarian administration to account.
I hope you received’t miss this second—donate to The Nation right now.
Onward,
Katrina vanden Heuvel
Editor and writer, The Nation
Extra from The Nation
Over 70,525 Palestinians have been killed in Gaza; students estimate that 80 % had been civilians, largely ladies and kids.
On this week’s Elie v. U.S., The Nation’s justice correspondent recaps a significant demise penalty case that got here earlier than the excessive courtroom in addition to the shenanigans of a person who’s angling…
Voters need the celebration to get powerful on the business. However Democratic leaders are following the cash as an alternative.
And but, that’s what the Supreme Court docket seems ready to do.
