Thanks for being right here. Welcome to what captivates, haunts, evokes, and surprises me each week on this planet of authorized ethics.
The Authorized Ethics Roundup neighborhood consists of greater than 2,100 subscribers throughout the USA and in 50 completely different international locations. Subscribers are legal professionals, judges, professors, state bar directors, college students, authorities officers, journalists, and individuals who care about the way forward for our democracy.
Should you haven’t subscribed, take a second now to enroll on the hyperlink under. It’s free! And also you’ll by no means miss the newest version. I hope you’ll additionally contemplate turning into a paid subscriber, which helps to help this article and demonstrates that you just worth its content material. Paid subscribers additionally obtain particular entry to previous posts which turn out to be paywalled after six months. (Should you want a comp paid subscription to learn an older submit, let me know at legalethics@substack.com.)
Did you uncover the Roundup by means of our collaboration with Above the Legislation? Learn extra about that partnership here.
Searching for the Authorized Ethics & Democracy Tracker? You’ll discover it here.
Do you’ve gotten colleagues who care about authorized ethics? Please share the Roundup with them. I’d like to see our neighborhood proceed to develop!
Howdy from Madison, the place we’ve been visiting the College of Wisconsin as a part of my daughter’s faculty campus excursions. (Thus far, we’ve hit the College of Texas and subsequent month we head to the College of Chicago. It’s making me need to return to varsity myself!)
It was one other week full of authorized ethics headlines, so your record under consists of fifteen once more. However first, I need to spotlight a particular employment alternative. (Normally I solely embody job listings month-to-month within the LER First Monday version.) Final week, Lucy Ricca shared with me that she’s accepted a brand new place because the Govt Director of Neukom Heart for the Rule of Legislation, which implies her job because the Govt Director, Deborah L. Rhode Heart on the Authorized Career, Stanford Legislation Faculty is open. This can be a terrific alternative — be taught extra and apply here.
#1 “Funding Disaster Leaves Protection Legal professionals Working With out Pay.” From US Courts.gov: “This system that pays court-appointed non-public attorneys to signify indigent federal prison defendants has run out of cash, beginning the clock on a painful three-month delay in paying these attorneys and their associated service suppliers for constitutionally mandated authorized work. The funding disaster has prompted concern all through the federal Judiciary that many of those non-public legal professionals, often known as panel attorneys, may decline new circumstances. That might depart defendants, even these on loss of life row, with out sufficient illustration.” Learn extra here.
#2 “DOJ’s Ex-Ethics Lawyer Speaks Out After Being Fired by Pam Bondi.” From Newsweek: “Lawyer Normal Pam Bondi has dismissed the Justice Division’s high ethics lawyer, Joseph Tirrell, in accordance with a submit he shared on LinkedIn. Tirrell, a Navy veteran, posted a duplicate of his termination letter on the platform Friday, noting that it resembled notices acquired by different DOJ workers. The letter included a typo, misspelling his title as ‘JOSPEH.’ ‘Till Friday night, I used to be the senior ethics lawyer on the Division of Justice liable for advising the Lawyer Normal and Deputy Lawyer Normal straight on federal worker ethics,’ he wrote, partly, on LinkedIn. ‘I used to be additionally liable for the day-to-day operations of the ethics program throughout the Division. I led a small, devoted staff of pros and coordinated the work of some 30 different full-time ethics officers, attorneys, paralegals and different specialists throughout the Division of Justice, guaranteeing that the 117,000 Division workers had been correctly suggested on and supported in the best way to comply with the Federal worker ethics guidelines.’” Learn extra here.
#3 “Authorized Group Urges State Supreme Court docket to Order Florida Bar to Examine Bondi.” From the Miami Herald: “Snubbed by The Florida Bar final month, about 70 liberal-leaning students, attorneys and former judges have requested the state Supreme Court docket to order the Bar to analyze their criticism claiming U.S. Lawyer Normal Pam Bondi violated Florida’s ethics guidelines because the nation’s high regulation enforcement official. The coalition’s authorized argument in a petition filed on Tuesday could also be compelling, however it’s an extended shot given the truth that the seven justices on Florida’s excessive courtroom had been all appointed by Republican Gov. Ron DeSantis and former GOP Gov. Charlie Crist.” Learn extra here.
#4 “Rubio Strikes to Strip US Visas From Eight Brazilian Judges in Bolsonaro Battle.” From The Guardian: “The US secretary of state, Marco Rubio, has reportedly stripped eight of Brazil’s 11 supreme courtroom judges of their US visas because the White Home escalates its marketing campaign to assist the nation’s former president Jair Bolsonaro keep away from justice over his alleged try to seize energy with a army coup. Bolsonaro, a far-right populist with ties to Donald Trump’s Maga motion, is on trial for allegedly masterminding a murderous plot to cling to energy after dropping the 2022 election to his leftwing rival, Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva. Bolsonaro is predicted to be convicted by the supreme courtroom within the coming weeks and faces a jail sentence of as much as 43 years.” Learn extra here.
#5 “Davis Polk Axes Affiliate Over Writings Criticizing Trump.” From Bloomberg Legislation: “Wall Road’s Davis Polk & Wardwell fired a junior lawyer following warnings over his op-eds knocking the Trump administration, in accordance with the lawyer. Ryan Powers, a former Davis Polk affiliate, says the agency fired him June 12. His profile was faraway from the location instantly, Powers stated in an interview. The Harvard Legislation graduate joined the agency’s tax group October 2023 and labored on offers for Cintas Corp. and Penske Truck Leasing. Powers’ op-eds included vital takes on the federal authorities’s surveillance of the general public, which highlighted Palantir Applied sciences. Davis Polk legal professionals suggested banks concerned in Palantir’s 2020 inventory itemizing. A agency human sources consultant notified Powers that his content material violated the agency’s inside coverage as a result of he was not granted prior permission, he stated.” Learn extra here. (For much more, here is a Substack submit from Powers about his firing.)
#6 “Fla. Choose Suspended Over ‘Unacceptable’ Political Donations.” From Law360: “A Florida state courtroom decide [was] discovered to have violated judicial canons by donating funds to the election campaigns of Kamala Harris and Joe Biden and improperly discussing her personal reelection marketing campaign.” Learn extra here.
#7 “Unearthed Chat Sheds Mild on Cozy Ties Between Judges, Local weather Activists, Elevating Moral Issues.” From Fox Information: “An environmental advocacy group accused of making an attempt to govern judges organized a years-long, nationwide on-line discussion board with jurists to advertise favorable data and litigation updates concerning local weather points – till the email-styled group chat was abruptly made non-public, Fox Information Digital discovered.” Learn extra here.
#8 “Sen. Coons Asking About Office Conduct in Nominees’ Questions for the File.” From Repair the Court docket: “Judicial nomination hearings are sometimes rapid-fire occasions the place members of the Senate Judiciary Committee barely have sufficient time to get out a whole thought, not to mention ask a complete line of questioning. Fortunately, there are two further components to the nomination course of: first, a Senate Judiciary Questionnaire that each one nominees should fill out previous to their listening to; and second, any senator on the Committee can ship Questions for the File to the nominee after their listening to, with the expectation that they’ll be answered (albeit not all the time in a passable method). There’s been a optimistic growth on the latter entrance: Sen. Chris Coons is asking questions on office conduct within the QFRs. This comes as a sequence of stories studies, courtroom filings, nationwide surveys and misconduct orders this 12 months present that the endemic issues of harassment, retaliation and discrimination within the third department aren’t going away.” Learn extra here.
#9 “AI Misuse and the ‘Snitch Rule’ in Authorized Ethics.” From the Every day Journal – Cal Lawyer: “Attorneys more and more use AI instruments of their apply, however misses of AI — equivalent to submitting fabricated case citations — can set off a reporting obligation underneath California Rule of Skilled Conduct 8.3” [And perhaps also under ABA Model Rule 8.4?] Learn extra here.
#10 “Michigan Legislation Provides AI Essay Immediate.” From Inside Greater Ed: “In 2023, the College of Michigan Legislation Faculty made headlines for its coverage banning candidates from utilizing generative AI to jot down their admissions essays. Now, two admissions cycles later, the regulation faculty shouldn’t be solely permitting AI responses however truly mandating using AI—at the very least for one optional essay. For these making use of this fall, the regulation faculty added a supplemental essay immediate that asks college students about their AI utilization and the way they see that altering in regulation faculty—and requires them to make use of AI to develop their response.” Learn extra here.
#11 “California Court docket System Adopts Rule on AI Use.” From Reuters: “California on Friday turned the biggest U.S. state courtroom system to embrace insurance policies governing using generative synthetic intelligence by judges and courtroom workers. California courts that don’t ban generative AI outright should develop AI-related rules by September 1 underneath a rule adopted by the California Judicial Council, the policy-making physique for the state’s courtroom system. The rule, was developed by a synthetic intelligence process drive established by Chief Justice Patricia Guerrero in 2024.” Learn extra here.
#12 “Trump Admin’s Supreme Court docket Legal professionals Give up.” From Newsweek: “Practically two-thirds of the U.S. Justice Division’s unit liable for defending key Trump administration insurance policies in courtroom, have left their positions since President Donald Trump’s November election or introduced plans to go away, in accordance with a brand new record. Of the roughly 110 legal professionals within the Federal Packages Department, 69 have departed or signaled their intention to depart, in accordance with the record. Reuters, which first reported the record, stated it had verified the departure of all however 4. The resignations may pose vital challenges for the unit that’s tasked with dealing with an unprecedented wave of lawsuits concentrating on the administration’s actions, together with restrictions on birthright citizenship and funding cuts to Harvard College.” Learn extra here.
#13 “Georgia Legal professionals Contemplate Restricted Function for Authorized Help by Non-Attorneys.” From Grice Join: “A committee appointed by the Georgia Supreme Court docket is recommending a pilot program that will permit people with specialised authorized coaching to offer restricted authorized help, aiming to enhance entry to justice for low-income and rural Georgians.” Learn extra here.
#14 “Federal Judges Set to Meet Monday, Possibly to Decide U.S. Lawyer.” From the New Jersey Globe: “A gathering of the U.S. District Court docket Judges from New Jersey has been set for Monday to presumably vote to nominate a U.S. Lawyer, the New Jersey Globe has realized. The assembly takes place amid uncertainties surrounding the tenure of U.S. Lawyer Alina Habba, whose 120-day time period is ready to run out on Tuesday. Below an extremely murky statute, federal judges, by a majority vote, could appoint a U.S. Lawyer if nobody has been nominated by the President and confirmed by the U.S. Senate. … A number of sources with direct data of the choice course of, talking on the situation of anonymity, have informed the New Jersey Globe that Habba doesn’t have sufficient help among the many federal judges to win a vote.” Learn extra here.
#15 “Joint Assertion from CLEA and AALS Scientific Part on Congressional Assault on Tutorial Freedom.” From CleaWeb.org: “As experiential school members educating and training regulation, we have now duties past these as school members with tutorial freedom — we’re representatives for our purchasers, officers of the courtroom, and public residents. Looking for to punish a lawyer for his or her moral and zealous illustration and advocacy compromises these core obligations. This, in flip, threatens the viability of our authorized system — a system vital to the preservation of our democracy.” Learn extra here.
Did you miss the 150+ job postings from earlier Roundups? Discover all of them here.
Did you miss an announcement from earlier Roundups? Discover all of them here.
