Maybe you’ve heard of the “Palestine Exception,” the concept all kinds of behaviors and speech which are acceptable in different contexts are denied and punished in terms of advocacy round Palestine. However what if the therapy of Palestinians wasn’t an exception however a stress check? A check of our tolerance as a nation and as a individuals, for cruelty and the consolidation of authoritarian rule. Authoritarians title an enemy, declare an emergency, and, on that pretext, invoke extraordinary, usually army, powers to shock and intimidate credible sources of opposition and dissent, together with politicians, the legislation, the media, the academy, free speech, and even the reality itself.
Mahmoud Khalil has seen each a type of steps up shut. A negotiator for the pro-Palestine pupil protests on Columbia College’s campus in 2024, Khalil was arrested and not using a warrant by unidentified males in March. He was one of many first and most seen abductions after the second Trump administration took workplace. Khalil, a authorized everlasting resident who had dedicated no violence and damaged no legislation, was taken from his pregnant spouse and transported 1,500 miles to a Louisiana detention camp with out entry to a lawyer or any technique of protection.
The Trump administration sought to expel Khalil not for his acts, however for his “beliefs, statements, and associations,” which Secretary of State Marco Rubio wrote in a brief letter would “compromise a compelling US overseas coverage curiosity.” About 100 days later and after Khalil had missed the start of his son, Deen, a New Jersey federal decide rejected Rubio’s case and ordered Khalil’s launch. However this September, the administration got here again citing errors on his green-card software and ordered that Khalil be deported, presumably to Algeria or Syria, the place his life could be beneath risk. He has till the tip of October to enchantment. Within the meantime, Khalil is suing the Trump administration for $20 million in damages, alleging that he was falsely imprisoned, maliciously prosecuted, and smeared as an antisemite. Khalil has stated he’ll proceed advocating for Palestinians as his authorized battle performs out, and that’s precisely what he’s doing.
Laura Flanders: How did you get linked with the motion that you just grew to become a negotiator for there on the Columbia College campus?
Mahmoud Khalil: Being a Palestinian already linked to the motion of liberation of your individuals—I used to be one of many only a few Palestinian college students on campus, particularly these coming instantly from a refugee camp or from Palestine. Since I left Syria, I had this sense of humanity, by way of like: I wish to discover justice; I wish to search justice and dignity. I began working with Syrians and Palestinians, Syrian refugees in Lebanon and throughout the area after which I got here right here and continued to try this.
LF: March 8 is Worldwide Girls’s Day for some, however for others, the day on which you have been, there’s no different phrase for it, kidnapped. What occurred?
MK: Following my involvement within the encampment in April 2024, there was a concerted effort to dox me and smear me on-line by many shady teams and in addition by Zionist actors at Columbia College. However I didn’t care about that, as a result of these smear campaigns have been designed to intimidate you so that you don’t converse. Nonetheless, when Trump got here into energy, these threats grew to become institutionalized. This anti-Palestinian sentiment has turn into institutionalized in a approach that the federal authorities was relying on these shady teams to get info and to focus on pro-Palestine advocacy.
But I used to be, to be sincere, assured nothing would occur to me. I by no means did something mistaken. I actually was protesting a genocide. I used to be in my college protesting towards using my tuition {dollars} to be invested in Israel. So there’s nothing mistaken about that. After which March 8 comes, I used to be on my approach again from an Iftar dinner with my spouse, and it was a Saturday night time. We’re wanting ahead to only go residence, have a cup of tea. Noor was eight months pregnant. I used to be adopted by plain-clothed brokers, and unmarked vehicles come and simply telling me like, “That you must include us.” I ask, as a result of right here you suppose you have got rights, “Oh, first, can I see your ID?” And second, “Do you have got an arrest warrant?” They usually declined to indicate me these. At first they stated, “Your visa has been revoked.” I used to be like, “I don’t have a visa. I’m a everlasting resident on this nation.” I can see them like shocked that I advised them that I’m a everlasting resident. The very last thing I heard whereas being arrested was them threatening Noor, my spouse, of arrest if she doesn’t go away me. After I was being booked, the very last thing I heard that the White Home is requesting an replace.
LF: Have been you in shackles at the moment? Did I get that proper?
MK: Sure, I used to be in shackles, principally throughout these like first 30 hours, more often than not when being transported from one place to a different.
LF: And any name to a lawyer, any name to anyone?
MK: Nothing. Regardless of my repeated request to name a lawyer, to name my spouse, which is just like the naked minimal. I studied public administration and public coverage, so I perceive the legislation to diploma a minimum of. They refused to do any of that as if they’re performing extrajudicially. And I felt it. I felt that possibly I’m being kidnapped. I felt like actually that what’s taking place to me was like, possibly I’d be killed now. Like I don’t know the place I’m.
LF: You fled Syria for worry of precisely this sort of therapy.
MK: Precisely, precisely.
LF: And got here to the US anticipating completely different and higher. Now it took a short while, however ultimately Marco Rubio, the secretary of state, releases a brief letter claiming that your beliefs, opinions, and associations pose some sort of risk.
MK: He stated one thing there that’s actually alarming. He stated that my beliefs, actions, associations have been in any other case lawful. He concedes that these are lawful acts. These are lawful associations. In the identical letter, he concedes that what I’m doing is lawful, he writes that regardless of that, “I wish to deport you as a result of I see this as a overseas coverage risk and compelling nationwide safety risk,” which is absurd. Rightly, a federal decide dominated that there might be willpower, or this letter in particular was unconstitutional.
The federal government is interesting that now within the appellate courtroom. I feel the federal government realized that they will’t win on that case. Now they’ve fabricated an entire new case that I made some willful misrepresentation on my green-card software. And it’s completely disgusting that they’re resorting to such fascist techniques, like actually fabricating an entire case. I wasn’t even requested about these allegations in my courtroom listening to, in my immigration courtroom listening to. Immigration courts are usually not precise courts, are usually not Article III courts or impartial, I’d say. They belong or they report back to the manager department. They report back to the Division of Justice and the lawyer common. So the immigration decide in that case principally didn’t take a look at the case, they usually simply needed to seek out me deportable. We’re difficult that as a result of it’s clear it’s in retaliation of my First Modification rights on this nation.
LF: Within the meantime, we’ve seen different individuals kidnapped, we’ve additionally seen the language ratchet up on this nation. Most lately, deputy chief of workers Stephen Miller described the Democratic Celebration as not a celebration however a home extremist group. Do you this so-called exception is definitely a check of our acceptance of authoritarian or fascist rule holds?
MK: The administration was not attempting to cover any of that. They stated that my case could be used as a blueprint, as a check case to go after everybody who, they don’t like their speech. And that is taking place now. This has been taking place to Palestinians and to pro-Palestine speech on this nation for numerous years. And as you stated rightly, this authorities thrives on division. That is why the Trump administration are utilizing Palestine, the pretext of antisemitism and combating antisemitism, to go after us as a result of they know that that is the weak spot of the Democratic Celebration. Once they go to the colleges, they begin with combating antisemitism, however then the second ask could be to abolish all DEI packages to sanitize the historical past on slavery and the inception of America. The listing goes on and on and on.
LF: I’d like to listen to what you’ve realized about how we may fight a few of this weak spot, come collectively over points that make lots of people uncomfortable.
MK: Unity is the method, and unity in a approach that’s a rights-based method. The proper of individuals to dwell equally in freedom and dignity. Lots of people bought so used to Trump, and they might say, “Oh, that’s similar to Trump. You recognize, that’s simply one other factor Trump is doing.” However I feel individuals mistakenly suppose that what’s taking place is way from their doorways. They suppose that this might by no means occur to them, whether or not, due to their social standing, due to their ethnicity, or on any of that. However what’s taking place round us ought to alarm us, it’s in our home. It’s not about that the US is changing into authoritarian. It’s authoritarianism now. Like I lived beneath Assad regime. I understand how that feels. I can sense the identical attitudes round me.
LF: That hasn’t stopped you preventing again. You could have introduced a civil lawsuit. What’s the standing of that?
MK: We’ll file the federal case very quickly to take the administration to the federal courtroom. That is about accountability, as a result of to me, silence just isn’t an possibility. I do know if I’m silent, that wouldn’t actually vindicate me or wouldn’t make my case any higher. They might nonetheless come after me and anybody else. The ethical value of remaining silent is far increased than any of those prices which will occur to me. I am going ceaselessly to Congress to foyer and advocate not just for my case, it’s for the cease of the struggle but in addition for elevating the alarm about what’s taking place round us.
LF: There are some heroic resisters, particularly amongst younger individuals who could be topic to serve within the so-called Israel Protection Forces. More and more, we’re listening to their voices, they’re talking up. There are some others inside Israel who see in their very own chief the same sort of fascist authoritarian who has his personal self-interested causes to remain in energy and is as unresponsive to any sanction by worldwide legislation. What’s your message to these individuals inside Israel?
MK: There’s completely no excuse to serve in a military that’s committing a genocide. So I completely applaud those that are resisting being a part of such a genocidal military, a genocidal state. As I stated it earlier than, our liberation is mutual. Our liberation is intertwined. You may by no means obtain Israel safety with out giving the Palestinians their full rights and vice versa. So this is the reason I consider in our collective liberation. And my liberation shouldn’t come on the expense of anybody’s liberation. And vice versa. Zionism might be a noble ideology of making a house for the Jewish individuals, however when that comes on the expense of my individuals, right here’s the issue. So equally, I would like to have the ability to understand my self-determination, respect others self-determination and dwell in dignity, freedom, and justice, prosperity.
