Cut up by the Taliban’s restrictions on ladies’s schooling in Afghanistan, the sisters hoped to reunite within the US. However new journey limits may jeopardize their plans.
Afghan feminine college students arrive for his or her classes at a madrassa, or an Islamic faculty, on the outskirts of Mazar-i-Sharif on April 8, 2025.
(Atif Aryan / Getty)
When Afsana, a 22-year-old girl from Kabul, acquired a scholarship to check in america, she stored it a secret from her father. For the earlier two years, she and her youthful sister, Nora, had been looking for a method to go away Afghanistan, the place the ruling Taliban barred ladies from secondary faculty and faculty (Nora and Afsana are pseudonyms used to guard their identities). In the summertime of 2023, the chance arose for Afsana to enroll as a junior at a non-public day and boarding faculty in New Jersey. Afsana was certain her father would disapprove of her leaving dwelling, but in addition certain that she may change his thoughts.
One night in mid-July 2023, one month earlier than she deliberate to depart, Afsana joined her father in the lounge for teatime and ready to interrupt the information as her siblings performed. Nora, sitting removed from her sister, feigned obliviousness, listening rigorously as she spoke. “I received a superb alternative,” Afsana instructed her father. She talked about how a lot the scholarship was price: $73,000 a 12 months. “I’m not going to let you go,” he mentioned, and instructed his daughter to not convey it up once more. Afsana instructed Seth Holm, former chair of the Trendy Languages Division on the faculty the place Afsana received a scholarship, about her father’s issues. Dr. Holm, who had been educating Afsana English on-line, despatched a video of the varsity’s closed campus, assuring Afsana’s father that his daughter can be secure.
On August 18, 2023, Afsana’s household took her to the airport in Kabul. Nora held again tears as she mentioned goodbye, harboring hopes to reunite along with her sister in america. Afsana hugged her mom and siblings, kissed her father’s hand, and took her first-ever flight to Pakistan for her visa interview, touring along with her brother (beneath Taliban rule, ladies cannot leave the country alone.) There, she met one other Afghan woman, additionally Holm’s pupil, who would attend faculty in New Jersey along with her. A month later, the pair flew by Qatar earlier than taking a 14-hour flight to Philadelphia, the place they met Holm and a consultant of AGFAF, the group that helped prepare journey for the 2 ladies. Afsana settled into her dorm, the place she would reside alone, a latest highschool graduate beginning over once more.
For the reason that Taliban took Kabul in 2021, women in Afghanistan have been discovering artistic, typically clandestine methods to proceed their schooling. Some attend secret schools, outfitted with their Qur’ans to faux they’re in madrassa—Islamic faculty—if the Taliban breaks in. Some women take courses on-line with worldwide NGOs. Some, like Afsana, discover methods to depart. Many have turned to America as a beacon of instructional alternative.
The 2-decade US occupation of Afghanistan helped forge this affiliation. In 2001, American-led coalition forces entered Kabul, taking energy from the Taliban and putting bans on women’ education. 4 years later, practically 1.7 million girls have been enrolled in major and secondary faculty, based on a UNESCO report. By 2018, this determine was 3.6 million. Literacy charges soared, practically doubling from 2011 to 2018. The narrative Western media sources instructed in these years was a hopeful one; images documenting the return to high school featured rows of heads in white hijabs, trained toward blackboards, and younger women beaming at their desks. The ladies in these tales wished to be astronauts, engineers, and teachers themselves. As the story went, Individuals had ushered Afghan ladies and women out of their oppressed state, into an age of equality. However that wasn’t the entire story.
The return to high school for ladies was generally deadly. In 2008, males on bikes threw acid at 11 college students and 4 academics on the Mirwais College for Women. From 2006 to 2008, there have been 1,153 reported attacks on academics, college students, and colleges, with women focused disproportionately.
Present Situation
Training facilities in Dasht-e Barchi, the neighborhood in Western Kabul the place Afsana and her siblings grew up, have been particularly weak to assault. The world is dwelling to lots of the metropolis’s ethnic Hazaras, who match into the Shi’a Muslim minority in Afghanistan, the place about 89 % of the inhabitants is Sunni, based on World Religion Database estimates. Traditionally persecuted, Hazaras seized new alternatives, particularly on the subject of schooling, after the Taliban fell in 2001. However an increase in violence ran parallel to features in schooling. Since 2016, Islamic State, a transnational Sunni insurgent group, has focused Dasht-e Barchi in a sequence of suicide assaults. Dasht-e Barchi, as soon as an emblem of alternative for Hazara college students like Afsana and her siblings, has was Kabul’s most harmful neighborhood. Afsana’s sister Nora remembers fearing assaults as she boarded the bus to class.
To Afsana, there’s a wicked logic to jihadist assaults on Hazaras. “They don’t see them as human,” she mentioned. “They are saying, ‘Now we have to erase these folks.’” Throughout her upbringing, this intolerance was palpable. Attackers focused Hazara college students, Afsana mentioned, to suppress the rising affect of Hazaras in Afghan society. Youngsters in Dasht-e Barchi confronted the specter of hazard and loss of life with an angle of resilience. Rising up, Afsana attended courses on the Kaaj Academic Heart with many different Hazara college students. As she studied, armed guards stood outdoors and on the roof of the constructing.
On the morning of August 15, 2021, Afsana left dwelling to gather her highschool diploma on the Ministry of Training. She noticed folks speeding previous her and felt unusual as she walked by the streets of Kabul. One girl stopped her and mentioned the Taliban had entered town. Terrified, she recalled tales her mom had instructed her in regards to the Taliban whipping ladies and barring them from faculty. Afsana went dwelling that morning, leaving her diploma sitting on the workplace in central Kabul. Later, she watched on TV as folks stormed the airport, determined to depart the nation. The Taliban had seized Kabul as the previous president, Mohammad Ashraf Ghani, fled. The brand new regime banned girls from secondary school. 4 months later, ladies have been banned from universities. Nida Mohammad Nadim, Taliban minister of upper schooling, mentioned the Taliban wouldn’t reverse its stance on women’s education “even when they drop a bomb on us.”
Afsana’s seek for alternatives overseas, which she had began even earlier than Kabul fell, grew pressing. She related with nonprofit organizations and joined Fb teams, sharing every thing she discovered with Nora, who was equally determined to proceed her schooling. At 6:30 one morning in June 2022 in Afghanistan, Afsana joined 19 different Afghan women and girls on a video name for his or her first English class with Holm (These courses have grown into the Afghan Training Pupil Outreach Program, or AESOP, which provides on-line courses, mentoring, and monetary help to round 500 college students a semester.) Motivated by the dedication of his college students, Holm satisfied the New Jersey faculty the place he taught to sponsor a scholarship for 2 of his college students. Afsana was a transparent candidate.
Having witnessed the dangers his college students confronted, Holm knew how a lot a scholarship overseas meant. “Getting them right into a scholarship isn’t nearly persevering with their schooling,” he instructed me. “It’s about bringing them to security.” One morning throughout his class, Afsana was giving a presentation about Sema, a whirling Sufi dance, when a suicide bombing came about at Kaaj Training Heart in Dasht-e-Barchi, killing 54 women. As information of the assault flooded social media, college students reacted within the chat. It wasn’t till Afsana completed presenting that she realized what occurred. Nora was a pupil at Kaaj Training Heart. She was presupposed to go to class that morning however had overslept.
Afghan emigration, traditionally male-dominated, has greater than doubled amongst ladies because the Taliban took over, with the quantity of feminine refugees hovering to three.1 million in 2023, based on knowledge from the UN Refugee Agency. A small portion of Afghan migrants go to america, with most going to Iran and Pakistan, however those that do face an more and more repressive atmosphere.
Widespread
“swipe left beneath to view extra authors”Swipe →
In an govt order from January 20, President Trump referred to as for enhanced vetting and screening of visa candidates and international residents. A whole lot of visa revocations, and hundreds of terminations in SEVIS, a digital dataset of worldwide college students, adopted. In March, Secretary of State Marco Rubio mentioned he had revoked at the very least 300 visas, claiming to have focused criminals and campus protesters. “In the event that they’re taking actions which might be counter to our nationwide curiosity, to our international coverage, we’ll revoke the visa,” Rubio told The New York Times. By April 24, the State Division had terminated the SEVIS standing of 1,879 worldwide college students, in some circumstances for no clear cause, based on a database revealed by Inside Greater Ed. Modifications in SEVIS spurred at least 65 lawsuits and motivated some college students to self-deport. On April 25, the Trump administration abruptly reversed course and promised to revive terminated protections. Such forwards and backwards exacerbated confusion for a lot of worldwide college students, contributing to the rising sense that their authorized standing solutions to the whims of these in energy. On Could 22, Trump halted Harvard’s enrollment of worldwide college students. 5 days later, Marco Rubio signed a cable ordering US embassies to stop scheduling visa interviews for college students whereas the administration expands social media vetting procedures.
As the method of acquiring a visa appeared more and more labyrinthine—if not unattainable—Afghans resided in a limbo of their very own. Within the govt order from inauguration day (the identical one mandating a visa crackdown) Trump ordered the secretary of state, legal professional common, secretary of homeland safety, and director of nationwide intelligence to compile a listing of nations “for which vetting and screening info is so poor as to warrant a partial or full suspension on the admission of nationals from these international locations.” The drafted list, which the Instances revealed in March, grouped 43 international locations into three classes. Afghanistan was within the “Purple” tier, which means the ban would maintain Afghans from coming into the nation altogether.
It was simply previous midnight in Kabul on December 14 when Nora logged onto her software portal for a small liberal arts faculty in Massachusetts, the place each she and Afsana utilized for early choice. Alone in her room, with Holm on the telephone, she opened the choice letter. Speechless, she shared her display with Holm, who teared up as he learn the letter of acceptance. Nora referred to as Afsana and realized that she, too, had been accepted.
Nora and Afsana’s household had cause to rejoice: Two of their kids would have the chance to proceed their schooling at a prestigious faculty. On the identical time, because the US cracked down on worldwide college students and visa candidates, the dream turned more and more elusive. Nora nonetheless clung to the hope of becoming a member of her sister within the US, nevertheless it was unclear how a lot of the Trump administration’s scrutiny of worldwide college students, its visa revocations en masse, and its plans for a brand new rigid journey ban have been bluster. The restrictions on international nationals and immigrants have been producing a type of vertigo that made it unattainable for college students like Nora to plan forward. “If I don’t get the visa,” she had requested in April, “what is going to occur?”
On June 5, Nora opened WhatsApp and found that Trump had restricted journey from 19 international locations, together with Afghanistan. At first, she thought little of the information. She instructed nobody and spent the day learning for her closing exams at AUAF, the American College of Afghanistan, the place she takes 5 courses on-line. Within the afternoon, she texted an official from AGFAF, the group serving to her apply for a visa, and requested if the journey restrictions would have an effect on her software. The official responded with as a lot info because the complicated circumstances afforded: She instructed Nora that the ban would possibly have an effect on pupil visas, however would hopefully be challenged in court docket.
Trump’s first journey ban, which he announced in 2017, confronted authorized scrutiny. However the Supreme Courtroom upheld a model of the ban, protecting residents from seven international locations, 5 of them predominantly Muslim, out of america (Afghanistan, the place US troops have been allied with the Kabul authorities, was exempted from the order.) The latest ban introduced it will bar entry to residents of twelve international locations, together with Afghanistan, and restrict entry to residents of seven others. One of many ban’s few exceptions applies to Afghans who helped the US within the warfare, which ended when Afsana was 18 and Nora, 15.
Late at night time, Nora spoke on the telephone with Holm. He reassured her that the school that admitted her and Afsana, in addition to authorities officers, have been preventing in opposition to the ban. The dialog, tough for each of them, lasted lower than quarter-hour. Nora went to mattress and lay awake, unable to quiet her anxious thoughts, till Friday’s early hours. The sensation took her again to the day 4 years earlier than, when the Taliban banned ladies’s schooling. “I couldn’t see any distinction,” Nora instructed me lately, tearing up, “between Taliban and Trump. They do the identical for Afghan women.”
Nora shunned speaking to her household, even to Afsana, in regards to the journey ban. The subsequent day, Afsana would graduate, and she or he didn’t wish to bitter the second. In the meantime, a buddy, meant to journey to Pakistan that week for her visa interview, instructed Nora she was unable to signal into her visa software website. Nora tried to open her portal, nevertheless it was blocked.
The day of Afsana’s commencement was humid, and her pink gown, capped with a stole the colours of Afghanistan’s flag, felt heavy. Her ankles wobbled in excessive heels as she tamed nerves earlier than strolling throughout the stage. Her aunt and a buddy, who each reside in Chicago, have been within the viewers, as was Holm. In Kabul, Nora referred to as her siblings and fogeys into her bed room to observe Afsana obtain her leatherette-padded diploma.
Within the days main as much as her commencement, Afsana wrote thank-you playing cards, paid visits to her academics, and postpone contacting Nora, ready till she had sufficient time for a correct telephone name. On the night of June 7, she flew to Chicago, the place she would reside along with her aunt for the summer time. Within the morning, she unpacked and referred to as Nora round noon. It was the second day of Eid. Nora instructed Afsana in regards to the celebration. Afsana requested Nora about her courses and her work at AESOP, the place she has been tutoring twice every week. She despatched Nora footage from commencement. And the sisters spoke in regards to the journey ban. “Did you hear the information that they banned the visa?” Afsana remembers asking. She inspired Nora to maintain learning, whatever the shifting circumstances past her management. Earlier than, Nora’s courses at AUAF signaled hope. Now the varsity, which acquired over half of its funding from USAID, faces the prospect of a shutdown because the Trump administration dismantles international help applications all over the world. In February, courses have been suspended for 2 months and grants for on-line schooling have been pulled. On their latest telephone name, Nora instructed Afsana that her academics, going through layoffs, have been in search of jobs elsewhere. Afsana countered personal despair with a present of energy. “You’ll be able to all the time be the very best,” Afsana remembers telling Nora. “It doesn’t matter the place you might be.”
The journey ban, Afsana instructed me, didn’t come as a shock. Nonetheless, the sisters don’t have any selection however to attend for higher information. “I actually, actually hope and I actually prayed we might begin faculty collectively,” Nora instructed me. “And I’m nonetheless hoping for that.”
Each day, The Nation exposes the administration’s unchecked and reckless abuses of energy by clear-eyed, uncompromising unbiased journalism—the type of journalism that holds the highly effective to account and helps construct alternate options to the world we reside in now.
Now we have simply the appropriate folks to confront this second. Talking on Democracy Now!, Nation DC Bureau chief Chris Lehmann translated the advanced phrases of the finances invoice into the plain reality, describing it as “the one largest upward redistribution of wealth effectuated by any piece of laws in our historical past.” Within the pages of the June print challenge and on The Nation Podcast, Jacob Silverman dove deep into how crypto has captured American marketing campaign finance, revealing that it was the highest donor within the 2024 elections as an business and received practically each race it supported.
That is all along with The Nation’s distinctive protection of issues of warfare and peace, the courts, reproductive justice, local weather, immigration, healthcare, and way more.
Our 160-year historical past of sounding the alarm on presidential overreach and the persecution of dissent has ready us for this second. 2025 marks a brand new chapter on this historical past, and we want you to be a part of it.
We’re aiming to boost $20,000 throughout our June Fundraising Marketing campaign to fund our change-making reporting and evaluation. Stand for daring, unbiased journalism and donate to help The Nation right this moment.
Onward,
Katrina vanden Heuvel
Writer, The Nation
Extra from The Nation
A vote for Zohran Mamdani is a vote in opposition to the Democratic Occasion’s reactionary heart and for a extra hopeful future.
The get together that constructed the New Deal now manages the uncooked deal. However there’s hope.
Mamdani and Brad Lander show they know how one can say “no” to a lawless president and his warfare—whereas rival Andrew Cuomo stumbles.
